The Valet's Tragedy, and Other StudiesLang, Andrew
History
The Valet's Tragedy, and Other Studies
Lang, Andrew
History; World history
In the usual blundering way, Mr. Pettigrew dates one letter of Dudley’s
‘September 27.’ If that date were right, it would suggest that TWO
coroner’s inquests were held, one after Amy’s burial (on September 22),
but Mr. Gairdner says that the real date of the letter is September 12.*
So the date is given by Bartlett, in his ‘History of Cumnor Place,’ and
by Adlard (1870), following Bartlett, and Craik (1848).
*English Historical Review, No. 2, p. 243, note.
The first letter, from Dudley, at Windsor ‘this 9th day of September in
the evening,’ proves that Blount, early on September 9, the day after
Amy’s death, went from Leicester, at Windsor, towards Berkshire. He had
not long gone when Bowes (a retainer of Leicester, of Forster, or of
Amy) brought to Dudley the fatal news. ‘By him I do understand that my
wife is dead and, as he saith, by a fall from a pair of stairs. Little
other understanding can I have from him.’ Throughout the correspondence
Leicester does not utter one word of sorrow for Amy, as, had the letters
been written for exhibition, he would almost certainly have done. The
fear of his own danger and disgrace alone inspires him, and he takes
every measure to secure a full, free, and minute examination. ‘Have no
respect to any living person.’ A coroner’s jury is to be called, the
body is to be examined; Appleyard and others of Amy’s kin have already
been sent for to go to Cumnor.
From Cumnor, Blount replied on September 11. He only knew that ‘my lady
is dead, and, as it seemeth, with a fall, but yet how, or which way, I
cannot learn.’ Not even at Cumnor could Blount discover the manner of
the accident. On the night of the ninth he had lain at Abingdon, the
landlord of the inn could tell him no more than Dudley already knew.
Amy’s servants had been at ‘the fair’ at Abingdon: she herself was said
to have insisted on their going thither very early in the day; among
them Bowes went, as he told Blount, who met him on the road, as he rode
to see Dudley. He said that Amy ‘was very angry’ with any who stayed,
and with Mrs. Oddingsell, who refused to go. Pinto (probably Amy’s
maid), ‘who doth love her dearly,’ confirmed Bowes. She believed the
death to be ‘a very accident.’ She had heard Amy ‘divers times pray
to God to deliver her from desperation,’ but entirely disbelieved
in suicide, which no one would attempt, perhaps, by falling down two
flights of stairs.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account