The Vivisectors' Directory: Being a list of the licensed vivisectors in the United Kingdom, together with the leading physiologists in foreign laboratories
Science
The Vivisectors' Directory: Being a list of the licensed vivisectors in the United Kingdom, together with the leading physiologists in foreign laboratories
Vivisection
Author of first section of “Handbook for the Physiological Laboratory;”
“Ein Beitrag zur Kenntniss der Structur des Zellkernes und der
Lebererscheinungen der Drüsenzellen” in Centralb. f. d. Med. Wiss. No. 17
(1879), p. 289; “Observations on the Glandular Epithelium and Division
of Nuclei in the skin of the newt,” Quart. Journ. Mic. Sci., No. LXXV.
(1879), pp. 261-404; “On the termination of the nerves in the mammalian
cornea,” _Ibid._, Oct., 1880, p. 459; “The organ of Jacobson in the dog,”
_Ibid._, July, 1882, p. 299; “The Anatomy of the Lymphatic System,” 1883,
London; “Atlas of Histology” (jointly with Dr. Noble Smith), London, 1879.
(_Chairman_) (3,538): What is your own practice with regard to the
use of anæsthetics in experiments that are otherwise painful? (_Dr.
Klein_): Except for teaching purposes, for demonstration, I never use
anæsthetics where it is not necessary for convenience. If I demonstrate,
I use anæsthetics. If I do experiments for my inquiries in pathological
research, except for convenience sake, as for instance on dogs and cats,
I do not use them. On frogs and the lower animals I never use them.
(3,539). When you say that you only use them for convenience sake, do you
mean that you have no regard at all to the sufferings of the animals?--No
regard at all. (3,540.) You are prepared to establish that as a principle
which you approve?--I think that with regard to an experimenter, a man
who conducts special research, and performs an experiment, he has no
time, so to speak, for thinking what will the animal feel or suffer.
His only purpose is to perform the experiment, to learn as much from
it as possible, and to do it as quickly as possible. (3,541.) Then for
your own purposes you disregard entirely the question of the suffering
of the animal in performing a painful experiment.--I do. (3,542.) Why
do you regard it then when it is for a demonstration?--Because I know
that there is a great deal of feeling against it in this country, and
when it is not necessary, one should not perhaps act against the opinion
or the belief of certain individuals of the auditorium. One must take
regard of the feelings and opinions of those people before whom one does
the experiment. (3,543.) Then am I wrong in attributing to you that you
separate yourself entirely from the feeling which you observe to prevail
in this country in regard to humanity to animals?--I separate myself
as an investigator from myself as a teacher. (3,544.) But in regard to
your proceedings as an investigator, you are prepared to acknowledge
that you hold as entirely indifferent the sufferings of the animal which
is subjected to your investigation?--Yes. (3,546.) Do you believe that
that is a general practice on the Continent, to disregard altogether the
feelings of the animals?--I believe so. (3,547.) But you believe that,
generally speaking, there is a very different feeling in England?--Not
among the physiologists; I do not think there is. (3553.)--_Min. of Ev.
R.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account