The Woman Who Vowed (The Demetrian)Harding, Ellison
Science
The Woman Who Vowed (The Demetrian)
Harding, Ellison
Science fiction; Utopias -- Fiction
"In the first place," asked I, "is it sure to bring a sensible benefit
to the race? And in the second, is the sacrifice a beautiful one? Is it
not rather inhuman and repulsive?"
"I shall answer your questions in the order you put them: Plato was the
first philosopher on record who proposed applying to the breeding of men
the same art as we apply to the breeding of animals--and he did not
seriously propose it; his proposition was spurned, as you know, by all
so-called practical statesmen up to the day of Latona, not because the
evil attending the existing system was not recognized, but because the
remedy proposed seemed worse than the evil. And, indeed, if men and
women were to be obliged to mate or refrain from mating at the bidding
of the state, one may well ask whether life would not become intolerable
to the point of universal suicide. The evil, therefore, remained
unabated. Consumption, scrofula, cancer, and other unnamable diseases
became rooted in the race on the one hand, and no attempt was made to
compensate the evil by selecting according to art. Not only so, but the
pauper proved the most prolific, the cultured the least prolific; so
that the breeding of man--far more important to human happiness than the
breeding of sheep--seemed contrived so as to occasion the minimum of
good and the maximum of evil. There seemed to be only two ways to
mitigate this curse: one, to restore marriage to the sanctity it
theoretically had under the canons of the church; the other, to appeal
to the self-sacrifice of a few gifted women. As to the first, Latona
believed marriage to be degraded in great part through the inability of
young men and women to choose their mates with wisdom, and she
instituted therefore the system of provisional marriage, tolerable only
in youth, and though possible in later years, tolerated then only under
extraordinary circumstances. As to the second, Latona instituted the
mission of Demeter.
"It is not easy yet to draw any definite conclusion from the practical
working of the system, for it has not been working long enough.
Nevertheless, it would be impossible, I think, to find anywhere a more
hopeful band of youths than those to whose education Iréné and her staff
are now devoting themselves. Indeed, wherever the cult is in operation
the girls and boys who proceed from the cloister are, to my judgment,
immeasurably superior in the average to any similar number drawn at
haphazard from the community at large. And, indeed, how could it be
otherwise? Heredity must in the long run count for a great deal; and by
securing to the Demetrian issue, not only the highest conceivable
education and parental care, but a sense that they owe something more to
themselves as regards standard of conduct because they owe so much to
the state, we create an environment which gives hereditary tendencies
the best possible opportunities for development.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account