The works of Francis Maitland Balfour, Volume 1 (of 4) : $b Separate memoirsBalfour, Francis M. (Francis Maitland)
Science
The works of Francis Maitland Balfour, Volume 1 (of 4) : $b Separate memoirs
Balfour, Francis M. (Francis Maitland)
Embryology; Zoology
Footnote 168: I find myself unable without figures to
understand Dr Rauber's (_Centralblatt für Med. Wiss._ 1874, No.
50; 1875, Nos. 4 and 17) views with sufficient precision to
accord to them either my assent or dissent. It is quite in
accordance with the view propounded in my paper (_loc. cit._)
to regard, with Dr Rauber and Professor Haeckel, the thickened
edge of the blastoderm as the homologue of the lip of the
blastopore in Amphioxus; though an invagination, in the manner
imagined by Professor Haeckel, is no necessary consequence of
this view. If Dr Rauber regards the _whole_ egg of the bird as
the homologue of that of Amphioxus, and the inclosure of the
yolk by the blastoderm as the equivalent to the process of
invagination in Amphioxus, then his views are practically in
accordance with my own.
Apart from disputed points of development, it appears to me that a
comparative account of the development of the meroblastic vertebrate ova
ought to take into consideration the essential differences which exist
between the Avian and Piscian blastoderms, in that the embryo is situated
in the centre of the blastoderm in the first case and at the edge in the
second[169].
Footnote 169: I have suggested in a previous paper
("Comparison," &c., _Quart. Journal of Micr. Science_, July,
1875) that the position occupied by the embryo of Birds at the
centre, and not at the periphery, of the blastoderm may be due
to an abbreviation of the process by which the Elasmobranch
embryos cease to be situated at the edge of the blastoderm
(vide p. 296 and Pl. 9, fig. 1, 2). Assuming this to be the
real explanation of the position of the embryo in Birds, I feel
inclined to repeat a speculation which I made some time ago
with reference to the primitive streak in Birds (_Quart. Journ.
of Micr. Science_, 1873, p. 280). In Birds there is, as is well
known, a structure called the primitive streak, which has been
shewn by the observations of Dursy, corroborated by my
observations (_loc. cit._), to be situated behind the medullary
groove, and to take no part in the formation of the embryo. I
further shewed that the peculiar fusion of epiblast and
mesoblast, called by His the axis cord, was confined to this
structure and did not occur in other parts of the blastoderm.
Nearly similar results have been recently arrived at by Hensen
with reference to the primitive streak in Mammals. The position
of the primitive streak immediately behind the embryo suggests
the speculation that it may represent the line along which the
edges of the blastoderm coalesced, so as to give to the embryo
the central position which it has in the blastoderms of Birds
and Mammals, and that the peculiar fusion of epiblast and
mesoblast at this point may represent the primitive continuity
of epiblast and lower layer cells at the dorsal lip of the anus
of Rusconi in Elasmobranchii. I put this speculation forward as
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account