The Works of George Berkeley. Vol. 1 of 4: Philosophical Works, 1705-21Berkeley, George
Philosophy
The Works of George Berkeley. Vol. 1 of 4: Philosophical Works, 1705-21
Berkeley, George
Philosophy -- Early works to 1800
69. Farther, the air being variously impregnated, sometimes more and
sometimes less, with vapours and exhalations fitted to retund and
intercept the rays of light, it follows that the appearance of the
horizontal moon hath not always an equal faintness, and, by consequence,
that luminary, though in the very same situation, is at one time judged
greater than at another.
70. That we have here given the true account of the phenomena of the
horizontal moon, will, I suppose, be farther evident to any one from the
following considerations:—_First_, it is plain, that which in this case
suggests the idea of greater magnitude, must be something which is itself
perceived; for, that which is unperceived cannot suggest to our perception
any other thing(357). _Secondly_, it must be something that does not
constantly remain the same, but is subject to some change or variation;
since the appearance of the horizontal moon varies, being at one time
greater than at another. [_Thirdly_, it must not lie in the circumjacent
or intermediate objects, such as mountains, houses, fields, &c.; because
that when all those objects are excluded from sight the appearance is as
great as ever(358).] And yet, _thirdly_(359), it cannot be the visible
figure or magnitude; since that remains the same, or is rather lesser, by
how much the moon is nearer to the horizon. It remains therefore, that the
true cause is that affection or alteration of the visible appearance,
which proceeds from the greater paucity of rays arriving at the eye, and
which I term faintness: since this answers all the forementioned
conditions, and I am not conscious of any other perception that does.
71. Add to this that in misty weather it is a common observation, that the
appearance of the horizontal moon is far larger than usual, which greatly
conspires with and strengthens our opinion. Neither would it prove in the
least irreconcilable with what we have said, if the horizontal moon should
chance sometimes to seem enlarged beyond its usual extent, even in more
serene weather. For, we must not only have regard to the mist which
happens to be in the place where we stand; we ought also to take into our
thoughts the whole sum of vapours and exhalations which lie betwixt the
eye and the moon: all which co-operating to render the appearance of the
moon more faint, and thereby increase its magnitude, it may chance to
appear greater than it usually does even in the horizontal position, at a
time when, though there be no extraordinary fog or haziness just in the
place where we stand, yet the air between the eye and the moon, taken
altogether, may be loaded with a greater quantity of interspersed vapours
and exhalations than at other times(360).
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account