The Works of George Berkeley. Vol. 1 of 4: Philosophical Works, 1705-21Berkeley, George
Philosophy
The Works of George Berkeley. Vol. 1 of 4: Philosophical Works, 1705-21
Berkeley, George
Philosophy -- Early works to 1800
74. If we attentively consider the phenomenon before us, we shall find the
not discerning between the mediate and immediate objects of sight to be
the chief cause of the difficulty that occurs in the explication of it.
The magnitude of the visible moon, or that which is the proper and
immediate object of vision(361), is no greater when the moon is in the
horizon than when it is in the meridian. How comes it, therefore, to seem
greater in one situation than the other? What is it can put this cheat on
the understanding? It has no other perception of the moon than what it
gets by sight. And that which is seen is of the same extent—I say, the
visible appearance hath the very same, or rather a less, magnitude, when
the moon is viewed in the horizontal than when in the meridional position.
And yet it is esteemed greater in the former than in the latter. Herein
consists the difficulty; which doth vanish and admit of the most easy
solution, if we consider that as the visible moon is not greater in the
horizon than in the meridian, so neither is it thought to be so. It hath
been already shewn that, in any act of vision, the visible object
absolutely, or in itself, is little taken notice of—the mind still
carrying its view from that to some tangible ideas, which have been
observed to be connected with it, and by that means come to be suggested
by it. So that when a thing is said to appear great or small, or whatever
estimate be made of the magnitude of any thing, this is meant not of the
visible but of the tangible object. This duly considered, it will be no
hard matter to reconcile the seeming contradiction there is, that the moon
should appear of a different bigness, the visible magnitude thereof
remaining still the same. For, by sect. 56, the very same visible
extension, with a different faintness, shall suggest a different tangible
extension. When therefore the horizontal moon is said to appear greater
than the meridional moon, this must be understood, not of a greater
visible extension, but of a greater tangible extension, which, by reason
of the more than ordinary faintness of the visible appearance, is
suggested to the mind along with it.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account