The works of John Dryden, now first collected in eighteen volumes. Volume 12Dryden, John
General
The works of John Dryden, now first collected in eighteen volumes. Volume 12
Dryden, John
English literature
[11] Cowley is now so undeservedly forgotten, that it is not
superfluous to insert his own excellent account of the free mode of
translation, prefixed to his translations from Pindar. "If a man
should undertake to translate Pindar, word for word, it would be
thought that one madman had translated another; as may appear, when
he that understands not the original, reads the verbal traduction
of him into Latin prose, than which nothing seems more raving. And
sure rhyme, without the addition of wit, and the spirit of poetry,
(_quod nequeo monstrare et sentio tantum_,) would but make it ten
times more distracted than it is in prose. We must consider, in
Pindar, the great difference of time betwixt his age and ours, which
changes, as in pictures, at least the colours of poetry; the no less
difference betwixt the religions and customs of our countries, and a
thousand particularities of places, persons, and manners, which do but
confusedly appear to our eyes at so great a distance; and, lastly,
(which were enough, alone, for my purpose,) we must consider, that
our ears are strangers to the music of his numbers, which sometimes,
(especially in songs and odes,) almost without any thing else, makes an
excellent poet. For though the grammarians and critics have laboured
to reduce his verses into regular feet and measures, (as they have
also those of the Greek and Latin comedies,) yet, in effect, they are
little better than prose to our ears: and I would gladly know what
applause our best pieces of English poesy could expect from a Frenchman
or Italian, if converted faithfully, and word for word, into French
or Italian prose. And when we have considered all this, we must needs
confess, that after all these losses sustained by Pindar, all we can
add to him by our wit and invention, (not deserting still his subject,)
is not like to make him a richer man than he was in his own country.
This is, in some measure, to be applied to all translations; and the
not observing of it is the cause, that all which ever I yet saw are so
much inferior to their originals. The like happens, too, in pictures,
from the same root of exact imitation; which being a vile and unworthy
kind of servitude, is incapable of producing any thing good or noble.
I have seen originals, both in painting and poesy, much more beautiful
than their natural objects; but I never saw a copy better than the
original: which indeed cannot be otherwise; for men resolving in no
case to shoot beyond the mark, it is a thousand to one if they shoot
not short of it. It does not at all trouble me, that the grammarians,
perhaps, will not suffer this libertine way of rendering foreign
authors to be called translation; for I am not so much enamoured of the
name translator, as not to wish rather to be something better, though
it wants yet a name. I speak not so much all this in defence of my
manner of translating or imitating, (or what other title they please,)
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account