The works of John Dryden, now first collected in eighteen volumes. Volume 17Dryden, John
General
The works of John Dryden, now first collected in eighteen volumes. Volume 17
Dryden, John
English literature
But not to dilate on that matter, I presume he will not pretend, by his
disputing, to make any thing plainly appear against her; if he can, let
him do it, and end controversy in a moment; for every one can see plain
things, and all Christians must be concluded by the scripture. But he
knows well enough there is no such thing to be performed. A mist may be
raised, and interposed, through which the eye shall not discern what
otherwise it would, if nothing but the due medium were betwixt, and the
object before it. And that is all the fruit of this sort of disputation,
and all the assistance, for which the answerer was so earnest. Upon the
whole, his mortal quarrel to the Duchess is, that she would not become
an experiment of the perfection to which the art of learned obscurity is
improved in this our age; and the honour he has done to the church of
England is, that he has used her name to countenance the defamation of
a lady. I suspected whither he would bring it, when I saw that honour
pretended in the beginning of his pamphlet. If he thinks his bishops have
reflected a scandal on his church by their discourses with the Duchess,
he ought to have proceeded a more reasonable way than to insinuate, that
she forged them, without proving it. If she had been living, and he
had subscribed his name to so infamous a libel, he knows the English of
a _scandalum magnatum_; for an inuendo is considered in that case; and
three indirect insinuations will go as far in law towards the giving a
downright lie, as three foils will go towards a fall in wrestling.
To conclude: I leave it to the judgment of the impartial reader what
occasion our answerer has had for his song of triumph at the end of his
scurrilous saucy pamphlet. I have treated him as one single answerer,
though, properly speaking, his name is Legion;[81] but though the body
be possessed with many evil spirits, it is but one of them who talks.
Let him disguise his defeat by the ringing of his bells: it was an old
Dutch policy, when the Duke[82] had beaten them, to make bonfires;
for that kept the populace in heart. Our author knows he has all the
common people on his side, and they only read the gazettes of their own
writers; so that every thing which is called an answer, is with them a
confutation, and the Turk and Pope are their sworn enemies, ever since
Robin Wisdom[83] was inspired to join them together in a godly ballad. In
the mean time, the spirit of meekness and humble charity would become
our author better than his boasts for this imaginary victory, or his
reflection upon God’s anointed; but it is the less to be admired that
he is such a stranger to that spirit, because, among all the volumes of
divinity written by the Protestants, there is not one original treatise,
at least that I have seen or heard of, which has handled distinctly, and
by itself, that Christian virtue of humility.[84]
AN ANSWER TO THE DEFENCE OF THE THIRD PAPER.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account