The works of Plato (Vol. 1 of 6) : $b A new and literal version chiefly from the text of StallbaumPlato
PhilosophyPhilosophy
The works of Plato (Vol. 1 of 6) : $b A new and literal version chiefly from the text of Stallbaum
Plato
Philosophy -- Early works to 1800
As there are two kinds of subject matter, he says, namely, soul and
body, so there are two arts, that which relates to the soul is
political; the other, relating to the body, he is not able to describe
by one name, but there are two divisions of it, gymnastics and medicine.
In the political art legislation corresponds to gymnastics, and the
judicial art to medicine. But flattery, perceiving that these four take
the best possible care of the soul and body respectively, has divided
itself fourfold, and feigns itself to be what it pretends, not really
caring for what is best, but seducing ignorance by means of pleasure.
Thus cookery puts on the garb of medicine, and pretends that it knows
the aliment best for the body; and again, personal decoration feigns
itself to be gymnastics. Then, he adds, what personal decoration is to
gymnastics, that is sophistry to legislation, and what cookery is to
medicine, that is rhetoric to justice; and so being proximate to each
other, sophists and rhetoricians are confounded with legislators and
judges[49].
-----
Footnote 49:
§ 44-47.
-----
Are good rhetoricians, then, asks Polus, to be esteemed as vile
flatterers in cities? Socrates replies that they appear to him to be of
no estimation at all. But have they not the greatest power in cities?
Not, if to have power is a good to him who possesses it. For what is it
to have power? is it to do what one wishes, or what appears to one to be
best? Polus admits that it is not good for a person devoid of
understanding to do what appears to him to be best. He must therefore
prove that rhetoricians possess understanding, otherwise, since to have
power is a good, they cannot do what they wish. Polus, however, is
unable to distinguish between doing what one wishes and doing what
appears to be best, and therefore agrees to change positions with
Socrates, and to answer instead of asking questions[50].
-----
Footnote 50:
§ 48-50.
-----
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account