The works of Plato (Vol. 1 of 6) : $b A new and literal version chiefly from the text of StallbaumPlato
PhilosophyPhilosophy
The works of Plato (Vol. 1 of 6) : $b A new and literal version chiefly from the text of Stallbaum
Plato
Philosophy -- Early works to 1800
_Cal._ I don’t know what you mean, Socrates: ask some one else.
_Socr._ This man will not submit to be benefited and to suffer the very
thing of which we are speaking, viz., punishment.
_Cal._ I don’t at all heed what you say; I only answered you thus far
for the sake of Gorgias.
131. _Socr._ Be it so. What shall we do then? Shall we break off the
discussion in the midst?
_Cal._ You shall determine.
_Socr._ But they say it is not right to leave even fables in the midst,
but a head should be placed on them, that they may not wander without a
head. Answer, therefore, to what remains, that our discussion may have a
head to it.
_Cal._ How importunate you are, Socrates! But, if you will be persuaded
by me, you will give up this discussion, or carry it on with some one
else.
_Socr._ Who else is willing? for we must not leave the discussion
unfinished.
_Cal._ Cannot you go through with it yourself, either speaking by
yourself or answering yourself?
_Socr._ That the saying of Epicharmus may be verified in me, “what two
men said before, I alone am able to say.” But it appears to be very
necessary. If, however, we shall do so, I think we ought all of us to
strive heartily that we may understand what is true and what false with
respect to the subject we are treating of: for it is for the common
interest of all that this should become clear. 132. I will, therefore,
go through the matter under discussion, as it appears to me to be: but,
if I shall seem to any of you to grant myself what is not true, he must
take me up and confute me. For I do not say what I say as knowing it,
but I am enquiring in common with you, so that, if he who disputes with
me should appear to say any thing to the purpose, I shall be the first
to give in to him. I say this, however, in case you think the discussion
ought to be finished; but if you do not wish it, let us give it up and
depart.
_Gorg._ But it appears to me, Socrates, that we should not depart yet,
but that you should pursue the argument: and it is evident that the
others think so. And I, for my part, wish to hear you go through the
remainder of the subject.
_Socr._ But indeed, Gorgias, I would gladly have continued to carry on
the discussion with Callicles here, until I had given him back the
saying of Amphion for that of Zethus[74]: but since you are not willing,
Callicles, to finish the discussion with me, yet listen to me at least,
and take me up if I appear to you to say any thing incorrectly. And if
you shall confute me, I shall not be angry with you, as you are with me,
but you shall be recorded by me as my greatest benefactor.
-----
Footnote 74:
See before, § 90.
-----
_Cal._ Speak then yourself, my good friend, and finish the argument.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account