The Works of Robert G. Ingersoll, Vol. 05 (of 12): Dresden Edition—DiscussionsIngersoll, Robert Green
Religion
The Works of Robert G. Ingersoll, Vol. 05 (of 12): Dresden Edition—Discussions
Ingersoll, Robert Green
Free thought
_Question_. Why?
_Answer_. Because the Koran was written by an
impostor.
_Question_. How do you know?
_Answer_. My reason tells me so.
_Question_. Have you the right to be guided by
your reason?
437
_Answer_. I must be.
_Question_. Have you the same right to follow your
reason after reading the Bible?
_Answer_. No. The Bible is the standard of reason.
The Bible is not to be judged or corrected by your
reason. Your reason is to be weighed and measured
by the Bible. The Bible is different from other
books and must not be read in the same critical spirit,
nor judged by the same standard.
_Question_. What did God give us reason for?
_Answer_. So that we might investigate other
religions, and examine other so-called sacred books.
_Question_. If a man honestly thinks that the Bible
is not inspired, what should he say?
_Answer_. He should admit that he is mistaken.
_Question_. When he thinks he is right?
_Answer_. Yes. The Bible is different from other
books. It is the master of reason. You read the
Bible, not to see if that is wrong, but to see
whether your reason is right. It is the only book
about which a man has no right to reason. He must
believe. The Bible is addressed, not to the reason,
but to the ears: "He that hath ears to hear, let
"him hear."
_Question_. Do you think we have the right to tell
438
what the Bible means--what ideas God intended to
convey, or has conveyed to us, through the medium
of the Bible?
_Answer_. Well, I suppose you have that right.
Yes, that must be your duty. You certainly ought
to tell others what God has said to you.
_Question_. Do all men get the same ideas from
the Bible?
_Answer_. No.
_Question_. How do you account for that?
_Answer_. Because all men are not alike; they
differ in intellect, in education, and in experience.
_Question_. Who has the right to decide as to the
real ideas that God intended to convey?
_Answer_. I am a Protestant, and believe in the
right of private judgment. Whoever does not is a
Catholic. Each man must be his own judge, but God
will hold him responsible.
_Question_. Does God believe in the right of private
judgment?
_Answer_. Of course he does.
_Question_. Is he willing that I should exercise my
judgment in deciding whether the Bible is inspired or
not?
_Answer_. No. He believes in the exercise of
439
private judgment only in the examination and rejec-
tion of other books than the Bible.
_Question_. Is he a Catholic?
_Answer_. I cannot answer blasphemy! Let me
tell you that God will "laugh at your calamity, and
"will mock when your fear cometh." You will be
accursed.
_Question_. Why do you curse infidels?
_Answer_. Because I am a Christian.
_Question_. Did not Christ say that we ought to
"bless those who curse us," and that we should
"love our enemies"?
_Answer_. Yes, but he cursed the Pharisees and
called them "hypocrites" and "vipers."
_Question_. How do you account for that?
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account