The Works of Robert G. Ingersoll, Vol. 08 (of 12): Dresden Edition—InterviewsIngersoll, Robert Green
Religion
The Works of Robert G. Ingersoll, Vol. 08 (of 12): Dresden Edition—Interviews
Ingersoll, Robert Green
Free thought
I see that it is contended over in England, that English actors
are monopolizing the American stage because they speak English,
while the average American actor does not. The real reason is that
the English actor works for less money--he is the cheaper article.
Certainly no one will accuse the average English actor of speaking
English. The hemming and hawing, the aristocratic stutter, the
dropping of h's and picking them up at the wrong time, have never
been popular in the United States, except by way of caricature.
Nothing is more absurd than to take the ground that the English
actors are superior to the American. I know of no English actor
who can for a moment be compared with Joseph Jefferson, or with
Edwin Booth, or with Lawrence Barrett, or with Denman Thompson,
and I could easily name others.
If English actors are so much better than American, how is it that
an American star is supported by the English? Mary Anderson is
certainly an American actress, and she is supported by English
actors. Is it possible that the superior support the inferior?
I do not believe that England has her equal as an actress. Her
Hermione is wonderful, and the appeal to Apollo sublime. In Perdita
she "takes the winds of March with beauty." Where is an actress
on the English stage the superior of Julia Marlowe in genius, in
originality, in naturalness?
Is there any better Mrs. Malaprop than Mrs. Drew, and better Sir
Anthony than John Gilbert? No one denies that the English actors
and actresses are great. No one will deny that the plays of
Shakespeare are the greatest that have been produced, and no one
wishes in any way to belittle the genius of the English people.
In this country the average person speaks fairly good English, and
you will find substantially the same English spoken in most of the
country; whereas in England there is a different dialect in almost
every county, and most of the English people speak the language as
if was not their native tongue. I think it will be admitted that
the English write a good deal better than they speak, and that
their pronunciation is not altogether perfect.
These things, however, are not worth speaking of. There is no
absolute standard. They speak in the way that is natural to them,
and we in the way that is natural to us. This difference furnishes
no foundation for a claim of general superiority. The English
actors are not brought here on account of their excellence, but on
account of their cheapness. It requires no great ability to play
the minor parts, or the leading roles in some plays, for that
matter. And yet acting is a business, a profession, a means of
getting bread.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account