The Works of Sir Thomas Browne, Volume 2Browne, Thomas, Sir
Religion
The Works of Sir Thomas Browne, Volume 2
Browne, Thomas, Sir
Christianity; Ethics; Religion and medicine
1. And first from great Antiquity, and before the Melody of _Syrens_,
the Musical note of Swans hath been commended, and that they sing most
sweetly before their death. For thus we read in _Plato_, that from the
opinion of _Metempsuchosis_, or transmigration of the souls of men into
the bodies of beasts most sutable unto their humane condition, after his
death, _Orpheus_ the Musician became a Swan. Thus was it the bird of
_Apollo_ the god of Musick by the _Greeks_; and an Hieroglyphick of
musick among the _Egyptians_, from whom the _Greeks_ derived the
conception; hath been the affirmation of many Latines, and hath not
wanted assertors almost from every Nation.
[Sidenote: _Of swans, and their singing before death._]
All which notwithstanding, we find this relation doubtfully received by
_Ælian_, as an hear-say account by _Bellonius_, as a false one by
_Pliny_, expresly refuted by _Myndius_ in _Athenæus_; and severely
rejected by _Scaliger_; whose words unto _Cardan_ are these: _De Cygni
vero cantu suavissimo quem cum parente mendaciorum Græcia jactare ausus
est, ad Luciani tribunal, apud quem novi aliquid dicas, statuo._ Authors
also that countenance it, speak not satisfactorily of it. Some affirming
they sing not till they die; some that they sing, yet die not. Some
speak generally, as though this note were in all; some but particularly,
as though it were only in some; some in places remote, and where we can
have no trial of it; others in places where every experience can refute
it; as _Aldrovandus_ upon relation delivered, concerning the Musick of
the Swans on the river of _Thames_ near _London_.
[Sidenote: _The figuration to be found in Elks, and not in common
Swans._]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account