The Works of the Right Honourable Edmund Burke, Vol. 10 (of 12)Burke, Edmund
History
The Works of the Right Honourable Edmund Burke, Vol. 10 (of 12)
Burke, Edmund
Great Britain -- Politics and government -- 1760-1820; Political science -- Early works to 1800
He says, "Nundcomar is a wretch whom you all know to be the basest of
mankind." I believe they did not know the man to be a wretch, or the
basest of mankind; but if he was a wretch, and if he was the basest of
mankind, if he was guilty of all the crimes with which we charge Mr.
Hastings, (not one of which was ever proved against him,)--if any of
your Lordships were to have the misfortune to be before this tribunal,
before any inquest of the House of Commons, or any other inquest of this
nation, would you not say that it was the greatest possible advantage to
you that the man who accused you was a miscreant, the vilest and basest
of mankind, by the confession of all the world? Do mankind really, then,
think that to be accused by men of honor, of weight, of character, upon
probable charges, is an advantage to them, and that to be accused by the
basest of mankind is a disadvantage? No: give me, if ever I am to have
accusers, miscreants, as he calls him,--wretches, the basest and vilest
of mankind. "The board," says he, "are my accusers." If they were, it
was their duty; but they were not his accusers, but were inquiring into
matters which it was equally his duty to inquire into. He would not
suffer Nundcomar to be produced; he would not suffer Nundcomar to be
examined; he rather suffered such an accusation to stand against his
name and character than permit it to be inquired into. Do I want any
other presumption of his guilt, upon such an occasion, than such conduct
as this?
This man, whom he calls a wretch, the basest and vilest of mankind, was
undoubtedly, by himself, in the records of the Company, declared to be
one of the first men of that country, everything that a subject could
be, a person illustrious for his birth, sacred with regard to his caste,
opulent in fortune, eminent in situation, who had filled the very first
offices in that country; and that he was, added to all this, a man of
most acknowledged talents, and of such a superiority as made the whole
people of Bengal appear to be an inferior race of beings compared to
him,--a man whose outward appearance and demeanor used to cause
reverence and awe, and who at that time was near seventy years of age,
which, without any other title, generally demands respect from mankind.
And yet this man he calls the basest of mankind, a name which no man is
entitled to call another till he has proved something to justify him in
so doing; and notwithstanding his opulence, his high rank, station, and
birth, he despises him, and will not suffer him to be heard as an
accuser before him. I will venture to say that Mr. Hastings, in so
doing, whether elevated by philosophy or inflated by pride, is not like
the rest of mankind. We do know, that, in all accusations, a great part
of their weight and authority comes from the character, the situation,
the name, the description, the office, the dignity of the persons who
bring them; mankind are so made, we cannot resist this prejudice; and it
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account