The Works of the Right Honourable Edmund Burke, Vol. 12 (of 12)Burke, Edmund
History
The Works of the Right Honourable Edmund Burke, Vol. 12 (of 12)
Burke, Edmund
Great Britain -- Politics and government -- 1760-1820; Political science -- Early works to 1800
If, however, after this explanation, your Lordships are
of opinion that we ought not to be allowed to take this
course, wishing to fall in with your Lordships'
sentiments, we shall abandon it. But we will remind your
Lordships that such things stand upon your records; that
they stand unanswered and admitted on your records; and
consequently they cannot be destroyed by any act of
ours, but by a renunciation of the charge, which
renunciation we cannot make, because the defendant has
clearly and fully admitted it to be founded in fact. We
cannot plead error; we cannot retract it. And why?
Because he has admitted it. We therefore only remind
your Lordships that the charge stands uncontradicted;
and that the observation we intended to make upon it was
to show your Lordships that the principles upon which he
defends all such conduct are totally false and
groundless. But though your Lordships should be of
opinion that we cannot press it, yet we cannot abandon
it; it is not in your power, it is not in our power, it
is not in his power to abandon that charge. You cannot
acquit him of that charge; it is impossible. If,
however, your Lordships, for the accommodation of
business, method of proceedings, or any circumstance of
that kind, wish we should say no more upon the subject,
we close the subject there. Your Lordships are in
possession both of the charge and the admission; and we
wish, and we cannot wish better than, to leave it as it
is upon the record.
The _Lord Chancellor_ here said,--The opinion of the
Lords can only be with me matter of conjecture. I
certainly was not commanded by the House to state the
observation that had occurred to me; but in the position
in which it now stands, I feel no difficulty in saying,
as my own judgment, that nothing can be matter in reply
that does not relate to those articles that were pressed
in the original charge; and therefore, in this position
of the business of reply, you cannot go into new matter
arising out of other articles that were not originally
insisted upon.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account