The Works of William Shakespeare [Cambridge Edition] [Vol. 4 of 9]Shakespeare, William
General
The Works of William Shakespeare [Cambridge Edition] [Vol. 4 of 9]
Shakespeare, William
English drama
II. 2. 46, 47. The first and second Quartos here read 'Bardoll, what
newes?' as part of Poins's speech, and in the same line with it. The
third, fourth, fifth and sixth have, '_Bardol_ what newes?' the seventh
and eighth, _Bardol_, what newes?' _Bardol_ being in italics. In the
Folios, '_Bardolfe_, what newes?' is put in a separate line, and this
arrangement appears to have suggested Johnson's conjecture. We have
omitted, as unnecessary, many of the stage directions which editors
have introduced into this scene, because the whole affair takes place
in the dark.
NOTE XIII.
II. 4. 245. Capell's misprint, 'how plain a tale,' which he corrected
in MS. as well as in his notes, was followed by Malone and other
editors.
NOTE XIV.
II. 4. 481. Johnson was the first to suggest that Poins and not Peto
should remain with the Prince. 'I cannot but suspect,' he says, 'that
for Peto we should read Poins: what had Peto done that his place should
be honourable, or that he should be trusted with the plot against
Falstaff? Poins has the prince's confidence, and is a man of courage.
This alteration clears the whole difficulty, they all retired but
Poins, who, with the prince, having only robbed the robbers, had no
need to conceal himself from the travellers.' Johnson's last-mentioned
reason for the alteration has less weight when we consider that they
all wore vizards. In favour of his conjecture we find that the Dering
MS. has 'Poynes' for 'Peto' in line 523, and in the stage directions to
lines 504, 508, 524. On the other hand, the formal 'Good morrow, good
my lord' is appropriate to Peto rather than to Poins, who was on much
more familiar terms with the prince, and rarely addresses him in this
play except as 'Hal.' We have therefore left the old text undisturbed.
NOTE XV.
III. 2. 174-176. The first Quarto, whose arrangement is followed in all
the other Quartos, reads:
'On thursday we our selues will march. Our meeting
Is Bridgenorth, and Harry, you shall march
Through Glocestershire, by which account ...'
The first Folio has:
'On Thursday, wee our selues will march.
Our meeting is Bridgenorth: and Harry, you shall march
Through Glocestershire: by which account....'
Pope altered the passage thus:
'On Thursday we ourselves will march: our meeting
Is at Bridgenorth; and Harry, you shall march
Through Glo'stershire: by which, some twelve days hence
Our general forces at Bridgenorth shall meet.'
Capell's arrangement, taking in the previous line, is as follows:
'On Wednesday next, son Harry, you shall set
Forward; on thursday, we ourselves will march.
Our meeting is Bridgnorth and, Harry, you
Shall march through Glocestershire; by which account....'
NOTE XVI.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account