The Works of William Shakespeare [Cambridge Edition] [Vol. 6 of 9]Shakespeare, William
General
The Works of William Shakespeare [Cambridge Edition] [Vol. 6 of 9]
Shakespeare, William
English drama
Malone supposes that a line following 192 has been lost.
Seymour proposes to read:
'that I am, have been, and shall be
....................................
And throw it from their soul (most firm and loyal)
Though perils &c.'
Jackson conjectures: 'that aim, has and will be, Though, &c.' or, 'that
aim has, and will be To you, though ... duty, And throw, &c.'
Mr Knight conjectures: 'that aim I have and will, Though, &c.,' 'will'
being here a noun.
Mr Collier adopts this reading, but takes 'will' to be a verb, for
'will have.'
Mr Singer reads: 'that I am true, and will be, Though, &c.' by which,
he says, all is made 'congruous and clear.'
Mitford would read: 'that am, and will be yours. Though, &c.'
Dr Badham suggests: 'that am your slave and will be. Though, &c.'
Mr Staunton conjectures: 'to that I am slave and will be, Though, &c.'
Sidney Walker says: "If there be no other corruption, the period after
'be' ought to be replaced by a comma: otherwise the words appear
unintelligible. Even so, however, this will be a most harsh instance of
ἀνακολουθία. But I rather think that a line is lost, somewhat to the
following effect:
'that I am, have, and will be,
[In heart and act, tied to your service; yea,]
Though all the world should, &c.'"
Mr Grant White adopts Mr Singer's reading, nearly: 'that am true and
will be, &c.'
Mr Nichols proposes to transfer 'yours' from line 199 to follow 'will
be:'
'that am, have, and will be yours
.................................
... and stand unshaken.'
Mr Keightley prints, 'that am, have and will be ... Though &c.,'
indicating that the sense is interrupted.
NOTE IX.
III. 2. 208, 209. The misreading 'may' for 'have,' which is so familiar
to us in this often-quoted passage, was not corrected by Pope or any
subsequent editor till Capell.
NOTE X.
V. 3. Mr Grant White suggests that a new scene should begin here,
"although the stage direction in the folio is only 'A Councell Table
brought in with Chayres and Stooles, and placed under the State,' &c.
But this is plainly the mere result of the absence of scenery of any
kind on Shakespeare's stage, and the audience were to imagine that
the scene changed from the lobby before the Council Chamber to that
apartment itself." We have adopted his suggestion, thinking that the
obvious propriety of changing the scene outweighs any inconvenience
which might result for purposes of reference. Hanmer, Warburton,
and Johnson all follow Pope in calling this Scene V. Theobald also
supposes a new scene to begin here, although in his edition the scenes
are not numbered. Capell, by his stage direction, indicated that the
scene presented the Council-chamber and the lobby both at once to the
eyes of the spectators.
NOTE XI.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account