The World of Flying Saucers: A Scientific Examination of a Major Myth of the Space AgeMenzel, Donald H. (Donald Howard)
Science
The World of Flying Saucers: A Scientific Examination of a Major Myth of the Space Age
Menzel, Donald H. (Donald Howard)
Unidentified flying objects
Unlike the amateur investigator of UFOs, both the storyteller and
the physicist know that if and when such advances are made, they
will enlarge our understanding of the cosmos, as did the creative
insights of Galileo, Newton, and Einstein, but new discoveries cannot
invalidate what we have already learned about how the universe works.
Many of the properties ascribed to UFOs imply a complete breakdown of
physical law. They belong to the realm of magic, not science. Traveling
at speeds approaching the velocity of light, reversing direction
instantaneously, achieving maximum acceleration or deceleration in
a fraction of a second, becoming invisible at will--such feats are
impossible for a solid body moving either in an atmosphere or in space.
Most of the serious proponents of the saucer hypothesis acknowledge
that such actions are impossible, according to our present knowledge,
but they argue that alien races more advanced than earthmen have
undoubtedly found new sources of power and developed new methods of
propulsion. Elaborate theories have been constructed, phrased in nearly
incomprehensible scientific jargon, to show that UFOs do not flout the
laws of physics but merely operate under laws that are still unknown to
human beings.
To UFO investigators whose professional training lies chiefly in
fields other than physics--business, the arts, entertainment, military
science, government, the law, medicine, or religion--such theories
might well seem plausible. But to the physicist they seem so irrational
that they do not even deserve discussion, and he dismisses them as
nonsense. Saucer believers thereupon denounce the physicist as a
bigot, complain of his “closed mind,” and piously invoke the ghost
of Galileo. They forget, apparently, that the persecutors of Galileo
were specialists in theology and had only a nodding acquaintance with
astronomy.
One of the earliest theories of UFO propulsion suggested that saucers
got their motive power by tapping the lines of force in the earth’s
magnetic field. One author wrote:
“The earth being simply a huge magnet, a dynamo wound with magnetic
lines of force as its coils, tenescopically [the meaning of this
impressive word is unknown to the present authors] counted to be 1,257
to the square centimeter in one direction and 1,850 to the square
centimeter in the other direction (eddy currents), indicates that
natural law has placed these lines as close together as the hairs on
one’s head. And yet they never touch or cross each other if let alone.
If done so by accident the catastrophe would spread like a searchlight
and destroy everything in its path.”[IX-20, p. 139]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account