The world's navies in the Boxer rebellion (China 1900)Dix, Charles Cabry
History
The world's navies in the Boxer rebellion (China 1900)
Dix, Charles Cabry
China -- History -- Boxer Rebellion, 1899-1901
A little thought would have shown him that they are in the
first place ridiculously easy to imitate, the first one needing but
a red blob on a white ground, and the second a little red ink, a
clear white stripe, and a stripe of the ordinary blue ink, make a
very fair tricolor. The first were also shown with the earnest desire
to propitiate, the second because, not being able to make British
or American ensigns, they thought that any protector was perhaps
better than none. Now so much has been said and written on the great
evils of looting, and especially on the looting of Tientsin, that a
summing up of the case by one who was to a certain extent “in the
know” can hardly be inappropriate or uninteresting. To begin with,
the evidence of many of those who have written articles to the papers
in denunciation of the authorities, or of the allied troops, is worth
but little, as it is more than probable that, by infringing some
of the rules, they lost what they themselves had looted, and their
bitter feelings may be accounted for by the fact that although it is
occasionally “better to have loved and lost than never to have loved
at all,” it is certainly not better to have looted and forfeited,
than never to have looted at all. Thus a proportion must be deducted
from the ranks of “conscientious objectors” whose argument is that
the transferment of some one else’s property to oneself is never
permissible, except it take the form of an exchange, a sale, or a
gift; also that the recognised law in civilised warfare is that
looters will be shot.
On the other side of the argument are to be found of course all the
participators, and a multitude of people who envy the latter their
good fortune, but whose envy does not go far enough to cause them
to act protector of the down-trodden, through the medium of the
press. These very rightly say, that in the first place the Tientsin
looting was not an incident in civilised warfare at all; “devilishly
cruel” has been already applied to the Chinese in this book, but the
superlative has not yet been coined which would adequately describe
the treatment of women and the wounded who fell into their hands.
Then again the power to “save face” is so highly thought of in China,
that had Tientsin not been looted, and had it not been decided to
alter the face of the city in other ways as well, it is probable that
one of the most valuable lessons of the whole war would have remained
untaught. Another excellent excuse was the fact that quite a third
of the city was in flames, in which case, had no looting taken place,
thousands of valuables would now be no more, whereas they have gone
to gladden the hearts of the womenfolk, and to brighten the rooms of
every nation of any importance from Japan westward to America.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account