Thoughts on the Present Discontents, and SpeechesBurke, Edmund
General
Thoughts on the Present Discontents, and Speeches
Burke, Edmund
Great Britain -- Politics and government -- 1760-1789
Therefore, the greatness of our
power, and the great and just opinion of our corruptibility and our
corruption, render it necessary to fix some bound, to plant some
landmark, which we are never to exceed. That is what the bill proposes.
First, on this head, I lay it down as a fundamental rule in the law and
constitution of this country, that this House has not by itself alone a
legislative authority in any case whatsoever. I know that the contrary
was the doctrine of the usurping House of Commons which threw down the
fences and bulwarks of law, which annihilated first the lords, then the
Crown, then its constituents. But the first thing that was done on the
restoration of the Constitution was to settle this point. Secondly, I
lay it down as a rule, that the power of occasional incapacitation, on
discretionary grounds, is a legislative power. In order to establish
this principle, if it should not be sufficiently proved by being stated,
tell me what are the criteria, the characteristics, by which you
distinguish between a legislative and a juridical act. It will be
necessary to state, shortly, the difference between a legislative and a
juridical act. A legislative act has no reference to any rule but these
two: original justice, and discretionary application. Therefore, it can
give rights; rights where no rights existed before; and it can take away
rights where they were before established. For the law, which binds all
others, does not and cannot bind the law-maker; he, and he alone, is
above the law. But a judge, a person exercising a judicial capacity, is
neither to apply to original justice, nor to a discretionary application
of it. He goes to justice and discretion only at second hand, and
through the medium of some superiors. He is to work neither upon his
opinion of the one nor of the other; but upon a fixed rule, of which he
has not the making, but singly and solely the application to the case.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account