It is an interesting fact that of twelve cases of echolalia that
have come under our observation, fifty per cent. occurred among the
blind. The coincidence is a rational one; blindness and echolalia
are united as cause and effect. In the case of the person born
blind the auditory memory is in such an advanced state of
development that, if he be not very intelligent, he will seek to
fix the sound of an auditory impression in his defectively
organised mind as soon as he hears it, and being unable to whisper
it mentally, he stimulates his auditory centres by a less delicate
process, and forthwith repeats aloud the word he has just heard.
This is why we meet with instances of the echolalic blind repeating
a sentence before replying to it. It is instructive to note in
this connection that the choicest example of echokinesis we have
seen was in a deaf mute, in whom no doubt the visual phenomena were
analogous to the auditory phenomena of the echolalic.
Noir is inclined to apply this mechanism to the case of echolalics who
are not actually blind. He quotes instances which go to show that their
visual memory is awanting, that as far as it is concerned they are
"blind."
The hypothesis is attractive. It may be further remarked that the
echolalia is a "motor," in the same way as the patient afflicted with
hallucinations of sight or hearing is an "auditory" or a "visual."
Echolalia is amenable to treatment, and is even capable of cure. Noir
gives an interesting example of the evolution of the process.
If I say to an echolalic, "Are you hungry?" he will instantly
answer, "Are you hungry?" Under the influence of re-education the
reply will eventually change to "Are you hungry? are you ...? Yes,
sir, I'm hungry," then to "Yes, sir, I'm hungry," and finally to
"Yes, sir."
Echolalia, however, is not an exclusive appurtenance of those who tic.
We can remember a case of general paralysis in the clinique of Brissaud
at the Hôtel Dieu, who had the regular habit of repeating the question
that was addressed to him; if it were a little long, only the last ten
or fifteen words were echoed. A case is quoted by Cantilena of a woman
with right hemiplegia and partial epilepsy who invariably reiterated the
closing phrase of anything said to her. Several cerebral tumours were
discovered at the autopsy.
It is conceivable of course that an actual lesion, as well as a
congenital developmental defect, may interfere with the will's
inhibitory powers, in which case auditory or visual stimuli are
transmitted to motor centres unmodified, the result being the production
of sounds or of other movements.
COPROLALIA
Coprolalia, the _manie blasphématoire_ of Verga, is, according to Gilles
de la Tourette, one of the most frequent affections of speech in the
disease of convulsive tics.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account