Tom Watson's Magazine, Vol. I, No. 3, May 1905Various
History
Tom Watson's Magazine, Vol. I, No. 3, May 1905
Various
United States -- Politics and government -- Periodicals
For the benefit of those who still cling to the belief that
constitutional wisdom had its birth with Washington and his compatriots,
I take the liberty of quoting a few extracts from letters written by the
Father of his Country before and after the constitutional convention had
finished its labors. These utterances of Washington are trite and easily
understood, and since their authenticity is unquestioned, they possess as
much of inspiration as any wisdom coming from him or his colleagues.
These extracts are contained in letters written by Washington to leading
men of that period, urging them to give their support to the adoption of
the new Constitution, and he pinned his faith to one argument, as you
shall see. I commend to all idolaters of that document a careful reading
of Washington’s opinion of it, and his advice to them.
Shortly before the convention met he wrote a letter to John Jay, bearing
the date of March 10, 1787. The convention assembled May 14 of that year.
In that letter Washington said:
“Notwithstanding the boasted virtue of America, it is more than probable
we shall exhibit the last melancholy proof that mankind _are not
competent to their own government without the means of coercion in a
sovereign_.”
There is no occult meaning hidden in these words. Washington had no
faith in the capacity of the people to govern themselves, and did not
hesitate to say so. In this, as I proved in a preceding article, he was
in accord with the overwhelming majority of the delegates who composed
that convention. The question I desire to ask is this: Was Washington
inspired when he wrote those lines to John Jay, and if not, when did his
inspiration begin?
Let us see what he wrote after the convention had finished its work. On
January 12, 1788, he wrote to Mr. Charles Carter as follows:
“I am not a blind admirer (for I saw its imperfections) of the
Constitution to which I have assisted to give birth; but I am fully
persuaded it is the best that can be obtained at this day, and that it
is it or disunion before us. When the defects of it are experienced, a
constitutional door is open for amendments.”
There is nothing evasive about this, but those who now repeat such
sentiments are suspected of treason by fools, and of a lack of patriotism
by unthinking conservatives. On February 7, 1788, Washington wrote to
Lafayette and said:
“Should the Constitution which is now offered to the people of America be
found on experiment less perfect than it can be made, a constitutional
door is left open for its amelioration.”
We have made that experiment. Have we found the Constitution perfect?
Where is that “constitutional door,” and why do we not open it?
Writing from Mount Vernon in October, 1787, to Henry Knox, Washington
said:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account