Towards an enduring peace : $b A symposium of peace proposals and programs 1914-1916
History
Towards an enduring peace : $b A symposium of peace proposals and programs 1914-1916
Peace; World War, 1914-1918 -- Peace
A second difficulty that will sometimes arise is the rule of conduct to
be followed pending the presentation of the question to the international
tribunal. The continuance or cessation of the acts complained of may
appear to be, and may even be in fact, more important than the final
decision. This has been brought to our attention forcibly by the sinking
of the _Lusitania_. We should have done very wisely to submit to
arbitration the question of the right of submarines to torpedo merchant
ships without warning, provided Germany abandoned the practise pending
the arbitration; and Germany would probably not have refused to submit
the question to a tribunal on the understanding that the practise was
to continue until the decision was rendered, because by that time the
war would be over. This difficulty is inherent in every plan for the
arbitration of international disputes, although more serious in a league
whose members bind themselves to prevent by force the outbreak of war.
It would be necessary to give the tribunal summary authority to decree
a _modus vivendi_, to empower it, like a court of equity, to issue a
temporary injunction.
In short, the proposal for a league to enforce peace cannot meet all
possible contingencies. It cannot prevent all future wars, nor does any
sensible person believe that any plan can do so in the present state of
civilization. But it can prevent some wars that would otherwise take
place, and if it does that it will have done much good.
[Sidenote: Enough if League meant peace for its members.]
People have asked how such a league would differ from the Triple Alliance
or Triple Entente—whether it would not be nominally a combination for
peace which might in practise have quite a different effect. But in
fact its object is quite contrary to those alliances. They are designed
to protect their members against outside Powers. This is intended to
insure peace among the members themselves. If it grew strong enough, by
including all the great Powers, it might well insist on universal peace
by compelling the outsiders to come in. But that is not its primary
object, which is simply to prevent its members from going to war with one
another. No doubt if several great nations, and some of the smaller ones,
joined it, and if it succeeded in preserving constant friendly relations
among its members, there would grow up among them a sense of solidarity
which would make any outside Power chary of attacking one of them; and,
what is more valuable, would make outsiders want to join it. But there
is little use in speculating about probabilities. It is enough if such a
league were a source of enduring peace among its own members.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account