Towards an enduring peace : $b A symposium of peace proposals and programs 1914-1916
History
Towards an enduring peace : $b A symposium of peace proposals and programs 1914-1916
Peace; World War, 1914-1918 -- Peace
Almost everybody hopes that, when this war is over, it will be possible
to secure the conditions of a lasting peace by reducing the power of
militarism and by setting the relations between nations on a better
footing. To watchers of the present conflict it seems an intolerable
thought that, after the fighting is done, we should once more return to
a condition of “armed peace,” with jealous, distrustful, and revengeful
Powers piling up armaments and plotting singly or in groups against
their neighbors until Europe is plunged into another war more terrible,
more bloody, and more costly than this. Yet nothing is more certain than
that this will happen unless the Peoples which are so vitally concerned
are able to mobilize their powers of clear thought, sane feeling, and
goodwill in carefully considered plans for a cooperative policy of
nations.
[Sidenote: The peril of “crushing” Germany.]
The first great obstacle to the performance of this task is the state of
mind of those who seem to think that all that is required is “to crush
German militarism,” and that, this incubus once removed, the naturally
pacific disposition of all other nations will dispose them to live
together in amity. It is not easy to induce such persons to consider
closely what they mean by “crushing German militarism,” or how its
destruction, whatever it does mean, would secure the peace of Europe,
we will not say in perpetuity, but for a single generation. But let
us suppose the most complete success for the arms of the Allies, the
slaughter or the capture of great German forces, the invasion of Germany,
and the dictation of terms of peace by the Allies at Berlin. Such terms
as were imposed might cripple her military power of aggression or revenge
for some years. But would it kill what we know as German militarism? If
our accepted political analysis be right, the German militarism that
must be crushed is not an army and a navy, but a spirit of national
aggression, proud, brutal, and unscrupulous, the outcome of certain
intellectual and moral tendencies embodied in the “real” politics and the
“real” culture of the nation. Can we seriously suppose that this evil
spirit will be exorcised by a crushing defeat on land and sea, followed
by a humiliating peace? If Germany could be permanently disabled from
entertaining any hopes of recovering her military strength, or from
exercising any considerable influence in the high policy of Europe, her
feelings of resentment and humiliation might perhaps be left to rankle
in impotence, or to die out by lapse of time. But nothing which the
Allies can do to Germany will leave her in such long-lasting impotence.
Even if stripped of her non-Teutonic lands and populations, she will
remain a great Power—great in area, population, industry, and organizing
power—and no temporary restrictions or guarantees can long prevent her
from once more developing a military strength that will give dangerous
meaning to her thirst for vengeance.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account