Our rifle competitions take too much time and are allowed to
interfere too much with regular training. Officers should not be
allowed to compete. Their work during this season is with their
companies; they should be learning the duties of an officer not that
of the private in the ranks. It is undoubted that a man can not make
much of a success teaching what he does not know. The officer must
know how to shoot well enough to be an instructor, he must know the
theory and have the knack of instructing. He does not need to neglect
his regular work for weeks at a time several summers to acquire this
at competitions.
The best company instructor in rifle firing the author ever saw on a
target range was a first sergeant who himself never made better than
marksman. The company was very short on sharpshooters and experts but
was still shorter on 3d class men. The poorest instructor he ever
saw was an officer whose breast on state occasions was covered with
big medals for shooting. He had to spare his own eyes so as to make
phenomenal scores; the instruction of the new men in the company was
of little importance compared with the former.
[Sidenote: Proper garrisoning]
The proper garrisoning of the army, to avoid so much necessary labor
and afford better opportunities for training, has been given great
attention by the War Department. May it soon meet with success.
But much can be done even under present conditions to help in this
matter. This beautiful parking perfectly kept is pretty, but it takes
ground needed for other purposes and requires an immense amount of
“fatigue” labor. This labor could be reduced: the parks would not be
so pretty but military efficiency would be greater. For which does
the government spend its money?
[Sidenote: Strength of the company]
Our companies should be increased in size to 100 men in peace, in
war to 150. Our companies are now too small for good training; it
requires too many new men to raise them to war strength, and the
present strength is wasteful of money and effort.
With the companies at a fixed peace strength of 65 it means much of
the time still less. There are not enough men to drill in the regular
platoon formations. In our extended order work the captain is
reduced to the capacity of a platoon commander and platoon commanders
are out of a job. These men do not get practice in the handling of
their proper units and it can not fail to diminish their interest and
enthusiasm and result in poorer work as well as in incomplete work.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account