Trevethlan: A Cornish Story. Volume 2 (of 3)Watson, William Davy
General
Trevethlan: A Cornish Story. Volume 2 (of 3)
Watson, William Davy
Cornwall (England : County) -- Fiction
allow the mere opinions and presumptions of interested parties to
outweigh the clear and positive declaration of an indifferent stranger.
Such is a brief narrative of the arguments and evidence adduced on each
side, in a trial which in fact occupied many hours. The judge now
proceeded to sum up the whole for the consideration of the jury. The
court had been densely crowded all day, and the excitement of the
audience ran very high.
Whatever difficulty, his lordship gravely remarked, there might be in
this case, arose from the deplorable manner in which the late Mr.
Trevethlan had caused his marriage to be solemnised, supposing for a
moment that it was a marriage. He fully agreed with the reverend
witness, Mr. Riches, in entirely condemning such a mode of celebration.
Marriages should be performed in public. But the plaintiff denied that
there had been any marriage at all, and produced an individual, who
swore that not being in holy orders, he took upon himself to read the
matrimonial service from the Prayer-book, and falsely and illegally to
pronounce Henry Trevethlan and Margaret Basset to be man and wife. If
the jury believed that witness, they must return a verdict for the
plaintiff, for it was not pretended that there had been any other
performance of the rite, than that to which this account would apply. On
the other hand, they had heard the evidence adduced to show, that Mr.
Trevethlan had always considered his marriage as valid, and that it had
been likewise so regarded by all who were connected with his family. But
then, again, it would seem that in the neighbourhood a very different
opinion had prevailed. Unquestionably the circumstances were mysterious,
and he could not but imagine that further evidence would be discovered
before very long. With that, however, they had nothing to do. They had
to compare a plain and positive story with a strong presumption, and if
they were unable to disbelieve the former, to return a verdict, as he
had said before, for the plaintiff.
His lordship then went minutely through the evidence on both sides, not
sparing the character of Everope, who, he remarked, would certainly have
been transported if he had been discovered to have really acted as he
confessed, within a certain time now unfortunately elapsed; and,
finally, he desired the jury to consider their verdict.
They requested permission to retire; and while they were absent, the
excitement of the audience rose to the highest pitch. There was a
general buzz of conversation. Every one was speculating on the result.
Bets were offered and taken freely. The bar were discussing the judge's
charge, and its tendency. Not a few people moved from their places to
try to obtain another sight of the defendant. None of the claimant's
family were in court. Randolph, perfectly unconscious of the attention
he attracted, sat like a statue. His leading counsel looked anxious, and
Rereworth lent his forehead on his hands, and seemed to pore over his
brief.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account