Trials of war criminals before the Nuernberg military tribunals under control council law no. 10, volume IIVarious
Philosophy
Trials of war criminals before the Nuernberg military tribunals under control council law no. 10, volume II
Various
Nuremberg Trial of Major German War Criminals, Nuremberg, Germany, 1945-1946; War crime trials -- Germany -- Nuremberg
A. According to my knowledge it represents the Golden Rule of the
medical profession. It states how one doctor would like to be treated by
another doctor in case he were ill. And in that way how a doctor should
treat his patient or experimental subjects. He should treat them as
though he were serving as a subject.
Q. Several of the defendants have pointed out in this case that the oath
of Hippocrates is obsolete today. Do you follow that opinion?
A. I do not. The moral imperative of the oath of Hippocrates I believe
is necessary for the survival of the scientific and technical philosophy
of medicine.
* * * * *
2. GERMAN MEDICAL PROFESSION
a. Introduction
The position of the German medical profession under the Hitler regime
was the subject of argument by both prosecution and defense. The
prosecution discussed the matter in the early part of its opening
statement (vol. I, p. 29 ff.). Selections from the argumentation of the
defense on this point have been taken from the final plea for the
defendant Blome and from the closing brief for the defendant Rostock.
These appear on pages 86 to 90.
b. Selections from the Argumentation of the Defense
_EXTRACT FROM THE FINAL PLEA FOR
DEFENDANT BLOME_[26]
* * * * *
Furthermore, I have another matter at heart, especially in my capacity
as defense counsel for this defendant: Blome was Deputy Reich
Physicians’ Leader; he will, therefore, to a certain degree, easily be
regarded as the representative of the German medical profession during
the Hitler regime. Now, there is great danger that the entire German
medical profession will be identified with its former leader, Dr. Conti,
and with the crimes he was charged with during this trial; the German
medical profession fears that those crimes which, _in fact_, were
committed by _individual_ doctors, who may have been rightly charged,
are to be taken as typical of the entire medical profession. Indeed,
during the last months we could hear in the press and on the radio that
the entire medical profession was here in the prisoners’ dock;
unfortunately, by thus generalizing, the matter was presented as though
the entire medical profession was corrupt and that the majority of
German physicians had committed such crimes or at least approved them,
as stated here in the indictment at the trial. This conception is wrong
and unjust. The German medical profession numbered about 80,000 members
and if we add the Wehrmacht physicians and the official physicians, one
arrives at about 100,000 physicians. Now let us compare with this total
number the small number of physicians and researchers here in the dock.
There are altogether 20 men. Of what importance is such an insignificant
number for the judging of the entire profession? If out of 5,000 German
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account