That this outburst is not entirely unprovoked or unjustified seems to
be proved by an extract from a public speech of the late Lord
Salisbury, in which he spoke of England’s antagonist in Egypt as
representing “the most hideous side of barbarism which a false
religion can produce”—this religion (the Mohammedan) being that of
sixty millions of British subjects.
“And here I would say: The time for these blackguardisms, the fashion
for these blasphemies, has passed. We live to-day in an age when
everything has to submit to the process of analysis. We no longer rest
satisfied with abstract ideas or despotic dicta. We insist upon the
results of exact observation and study; we ask for concrete, logical
judgment. You must study the Mohammedan faith; you must institute a
fair, well-balanced comparison between our creed and other religions
before you are in a position to judge, much less to condemn. Is such a
comparison feasible? To my mind it is a task of supreme difficulty, and
yet without an attempt in that direction it is impossible to be fair and
unbiased towards the Mohammedan world.”
An accusation against Islam which Midhat resented more than any other
was its supposed antagonism to letters and learning, an accusation
which, by the way, is sufficiently refuted by the history of the Moors
in Spain. In this connexion Midhat used to cite the following words of
the Koran: “Advance with your lances in order to make room for your
pens”—the term for “lance” and “pen” being identical in Arabic. The
Koran thus intended to convey the idea that warlike advance was only to
make way for opportunities of culture and enlightenment.
Talking one day to Midhat on these and kindred matters, I said:
“Midhat, they tell me at a certain Embassy that you are a fanatical old
Turk who hates the stranger within the gates; though, to be frank with
you, if I were a Turk, I too should hate them with a vengeance, after
all the uncharitable things they say about Turkey.”
“And I tell you,” replied Midhat, “that you have only to read up the
unbiased records of our history to learn that tolerance is the very
basis of our conduct. Does not the word of Mohammed tell us: ‘Whosoever
does wrong unto a Christian or a Jew shall find me as his accuser on the
Day of Judgment’? Do not the Jews and the Mohammedans keep the same
fasts and almost the same festivals? The principal difference I detect
between them and us is that the Jews do not believe in Christ or
Mohammed; whereas the Mohammedans believe in Moses, Christ, and the
Prophets.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account