Twenty-five years of the Philadelphia Orchestra, 1900-1925Wister, Frances Anne
History
Twenty-five years of the Philadelphia Orchestra, 1900-1925
Wister, Frances Anne
Philadelphia Orchestra
“Asked about his plans for the concerts to be given
this winter, Mr. Pohlig talked unhesitatingly and with
enthusiasm. The first question put to him involved the
type of music he would arrange for Philadelphia music
lovers, and was a query whether this would be of the
same nature he would have furnished a German audience.
He said promptly: ‘Of course, Philadelphia should get
the best and previous programmes show it has been
getting it. And, of course, it must get everything. All
schools of music should be represented. If anything, a
modern conductor must be cosmopolitan.’
“His mode of arranging his programmes will be new to
Philadelphia concert-goers, who have been accustomed
to a programme with the symphony either at the opening
of the concert or at the end. Mr. Pohlig will have the
symphony divide the programme into two, where it serves
the purpose of balancing the music of the recital. He
intends, if the opportunity offers, to combine with
local singing organizations for the production of
music for chorus and orchestra hitherto unheard in
America. His belief in the great spirit of modern music
will give Philadelphians the chance of hearing the
compositions of European contemporaries....”
* * * * *
Pohlig’s first New York concert on November 5th, 1907, did not meet
with approval, which considering the programme presented is not
strange, but the comments were of such a nature as to call down the
wrath of at least one Philadelphia newspaper which retorted in kind. As
New York has since capitulated this can be inserted.
A Philadelphia Newspaper, November 7th, 1907:
“POHLIG IN NEW YORK. FLINGS BY MUSICAL CRITICS AT THE
PHILADELPHIA ORCHESTRA AND ITS NEW CONDUCTOR
“The views of the musical critics of New York
concerning Carl Pohlig upon his first appearance with
the Philadelphia Orchestra in that city on Tuesday
evening are not altogether flattering. The _Sun_,
as might be expected, leads in its light-hearted
attack. Pohlig ‘is employed in the pleasant city of
Philadelphia, where he conducts the local orchestra.
Its work was so rough as to cause wonder that the
organization should have been brought all the way
across the State of New Jersey.’
“The _Times_ says that ‘the orchestra is a good
assemblage of musicians that clearly brought all of Mr.
Pohlig’s intentions to realization. He is a strenuous
conductor of advanced view as to the treatment not only
of Liszt but also of Beethoven.’
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account