“Long after the Civil War, General Sherman, defending the conduct of
his troops in South Carolina, said to Carl Schurz: ‘Before we got
out of that state the men had so accustomed themselves to destroying
everything along the line of march that sometimes, when I had my
headquarters in a house, that house began to burn before I was
fairly out of it. The truth is—human nature is human nature. You
take the best lot of young men—all church members if you please—and
put them into an army and let them invade an enemy’s country and let
them live upon it for any length, and they will gradually lose all
principle[262] and self-restraint to a degree beyond the control of
discipline. It has always been so and always will be so.’”[263]
(=12=) An anonymous author writes thus:[264]
“Real war is a very different thing from the painted image that you
see at a parade or review. But it is the painted image that makes it
popular. The waving plumes, the gay uniforms, the flashing swords,
the disciplined march of innumerable feet, the clear-voiced trumpet,
the intoxicating strains of martial music, the pomp, the sound, and
the spectacle—these are the incitements to war and to the profession
of the soldier. They are not what they are. But they still form a
popular prelude to a woeful pandemonium. And when war bursts out it
is at first, as a rule, but a small minority even of the peoples
engaged that really sees and feels its horrors. The populace is fed
by excitements; the defeats are covered up; in most countries the
lists of killed and wounded are suppressed or postponed; victories
are magnified; successful generals are acclaimed, and the military
hero becomes the idol of the people. The over-fed, seedy malingerers
of a small society join with the starving loiterers about the gin
palace in applauding the execution of ruin. If their heroes are
successful, what are their trophies?—prisons crowded with captives,
hospitals filled with sick and wounded, towns sacked, farms burnt,
fields laid waste, taxes raised, plenty converted to scarcity or
famine, and vast debts accumulated for posterity. Then when these
[military] heroes have done their work, the heroes of peace ...
appear, and by long and patient labor amid scenes of universal
lamentation seek to mitigate the suffering of their repentant
fellow-countrymen.”
The poet Byron was in a war and described war thus:
“All the mind would shrink from of excesses;
All the body perpetrates of bad;
All that we read, hear, dream, of man’s distresses;
All that the devil would do if run stark mad;
All that defies the worst which pen expresses;
All that by which hell is peopled, or is sad
As hell—mere mortals who their power abuse—
Was here (as heretofore and since) let loose....
War’s a brain-spattering art.”[265]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account