Water Reptiles of the Past and PresentWilliston, Samuel Wendell
Science
Water Reptiles of the Past and Present
Williston, Samuel Wendell
Aquatic reptiles; Aquatic reptiles, Fossil
Scheuchzer, while walking one day with his friend Langhans
in the vicinity of Altorf, a village and university of
Nuremburg, went to the vicinity of the gallows to make some
researches. Langhans, who had entered the inclosure of
the gallows, found a piece of limestone containing eight
dorsal vertebrae, of a black color and shining. Seized,
says Scheuchzer, with a panic terror, Langhans threw the
fragment of limestone beyond the wall of the inclosure, and
Scheuchzer, picking it up, preserved two of the vertebrae
which he believed to be human, and which he figured in his
book, _Piscium Querulae_.
About the same time another observer by the name of Baier discovered
other and similar vertebrae in the vicinity of Altorf which he
described and figured as those of a fish; and there was much earnest
contention between Scheuchzer and Baier, as also between their friends,
as to their supposed nature. Scheuchzer’s figure was often cited as
indubitable evidence of the destruction of mankind by a universal
flood, and it was not until nearly a century later that Cuvier showed
that the bones were really those of a marine reptile.
[Illustration: FIG. 51.—Restoration of _Ichthyosaurus_ with young, by
Charles R. Knight. (By permission of the American Museum of Natural
History.)]
It must be recollected, in extenuation of so extraordinary a blunder
on the part of so learned a man as was Scheuchzer, who, as a physician
and professor, one would think ought to have been able to distinguish
between vertebrae so different as are those of an ichthyosaur and a
man, that, during all of the eighteenth century and well into the
nineteenth, the belief was prevalent that all fossils were the relics
of animals and plants that had perished in the great biblical flood.
The science of geology was yet in its infancy, and there was no known
record, other than the biblical one, of any great inundation of the
earth’s surface which might account for the remains of sea-animals
in rocks remote from the seas. This belief, so long held by even
the wisest and most learned of scholars, so long welcomed by the
theologians as proof of the literal accuracy of the Bible, was one
of which Scheuchzer was quite convinced. His _Piscium Querulae_ was
largely a fantastic discussion of the supposed great world-catastrophe,
the Noachian Deluge, by which the fishes had been destroyed and long
imprisoned in the rocks through no sin of their own.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account