Wesley's Designated Successor: The Life, Letters, and Literary Labours of the Rev. John William Fletcher, Vicar of Madeley, ShropshireTyerman, L. (Luke)
Religion
Wesley's Designated Successor: The Life, Letters, and Literary Labours of the Rev. John William Fletcher, Vicar of Madeley, Shropshire
Tyerman, L. (Luke)
Fletcher, John, 1729-1785
No sooner was the publication of his “Scripture Scales,” or “Equal Check
to Pharisaism and Antinomianism,” completed, than he committed to the
press the following: “The Fictitious and the Genuine Creed: Being ‘A
Creed for Arminians,’ composed by Richard Hill, Esq.; to which is
opposed ‘A Creed for those who believe that _Christ tasted death for
every man_.’ By the author of the ‘Checks to Antinomianism.’ London,
1775.” 12mo, 52 pp.
The reader will remember that, in bad taste, Fletcher, in 1772, had
published, in his “Fourth Check to Antinomianism,” a “sweet gospel
proclamation: Given at Geneva, and signed by four of His Majesty’s
principal Secretaries of State for the Predestination Department—John
Calvin, Dr. Crisp, The Author of P.O.” (Richard Hill), “and Rowland
Hill.” This provoked Richard Hill; and, when he published his “Three
Letters written to the Rev. J. Fletcher, in the year 1773,” he, in
equally bad taste, attached an “Appendix” to his Letters, entitled, “A
Creed for Arminians and Perfectionists.” Now, in 1775, Fletcher felt it
his duty to examine the Creed so ingeniously drawn up by Mr. Hill, and
to expose its fallacies. The following is an extract from Fletcher’s
preface:—
“With regard to our extensive views of Christ’s redemption by price,
Mr. Hill calls us _Arminians_: and with respect to our believing that
there is no perfect faith, no perfect repentance in the grave; that
the _Christian_ graces of repentance, faith, hope, patience, etc.,
must be perfected _here_ or never; and with respect to our
_confidence_ that Christ’s blood, fully applied by His Spirit, and
apprehended by faith, can cleanse our hearts from all unrighteousness
before we go into the purgatory of the _Calvinists_, or into that of
the _papists_, that is, before we go into the valley of the shadow of
death, or into the suburbs of hell—with respect to this _belief_ and
_confidence_, I say, Mr. Hill calls us _Perfectionists_; and,
appearing once more upon the stage of our controversy, he has lately
presented the public with what he calls, ‘_A Creed for Arminians and
Perfectionists_’, which he introduces in these words: ‘_The following
confession of faith, however shocking, not to say blasphemous, it may
appear to the humble Christian, must inevitably be adopted, if not in
express words_, yet, _in substance, by every Arminian_ and
_Perfectionist whatsoever; though the last article of it chiefly
concerns such as are ordained ministers in the Church of England_.’
And, as among such ministers, Mr. J. Wesley, Mr. W. Sellon, and myself
peculiarly oppose Mr. Hill’s Calvinian doctrines of _absolute
election_ and _reprobation_, and of a _death-purgatory_, he has put
the initial letters of our names to his Creed; hoping, no doubt, to
make us peculiarly ashamed of our principles. And, indeed, so should
we be, if any ‘_blasphemous_’ or ‘_shocking_’ consequence
‘_inevitably_’ flowed from them.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account