When You Don't Know Where to Turn: A Self-Diagnosing Guide to Counseling and TherapyBartlett, Steven J.
Science
When You Don't Know Where to Turn: A Self-Diagnosing Guide to Counseling and Therapy
Bartlett, Steven J.
Consumer education; Counseling; Psychotherapy
Dr. Cantwell decided to use a combination of desensitization and
assertiveness training with Anne. During half of each weekly session
with Dr. Cantwell, Anne was asked to relax in a recliner with her eyes
closed, and Dr. Cantwell would then describe situations low on her
hierarchy. Anne was to try to maintain her sense of relaxation _in
spite of_ Dr. Cantwell's description of an imagined situation involving
Anne's neighbor. She was to imagine that her neighbor, who was very
fastidious about her own yard, knocked at Anne's door to complain about
Anne's habit of setting the trash out the night before pickup.
Gradually, in a similarly concrete way, Dr. Cantwell had Anne imagine
her mother criticizing Anne for using the same sponge for wiping up
{181} in the kitchen as for washing the dishes; a boss asking Anne to
retype a business letter using another format that he preferred; Anne's
mother-in-law "dropping the hint" that her son liked to have his
T-shirts ironed; Anne's husband complaining because Anne always
overcooked the soft-boiled eggs.
During the second half of each session with Anne, Dr. Cantwell played
roles with Anne in which he taught her how to assert herself more in
situations involving criticism. In one session, for example, he took
the part of Anne's mother and chose a typical remark she might make:
"Annie, dear, don't you think it would be smarter to use a different
sponge for wiping the kitchen counter? You should use a separate one
for the dishes." Dr. Cantwell then asked Anne to think of a way she
could reply to her mother's "nice" criticism, without feeling bad about
herself, without "getting hooked."
ANNE: Well, one way you've taught me would be to use humor: I could
say to her, "Mom, anytime you'd like to come over to do the dishes,
it would be fine with me." And then laugh.
DR. C.: That's a good approach. But you don't want to be
offensive; you don't want to laugh _mockingly_. _How_ you do this
is important. You want to set a good-natured feeling. Humor can
be very useful to offset the sting of criticism. Can you think of
a different way to reply to your mother, in addition to humor?
ANNE: Well, let's see.... Yes, well, I could go with her
suggestion and not interpret what she says to me as criticism at
all. I could say, "Mom, thanks for the idea. Maybe I'll do that."
DR. C.: Sounds very good. That's another way. The more
alternatives you can prepare yourself with ahead of time, the less
likely she will hook you, leaving you with nothing to say and
simply feeling bad. Would you try to think of one more
alternative? What other tack could you take?
ANNE: (After a moment of silence.) I can't think of another.
DR. C.: How about telling your mother how you actually feel when
she criticizes you? How _do_ you feel?
ANNE: Well, I wish she'd say some positive things instead, at least
sometimes. That would be nice.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account