Wit and its relation to the unconsciousFreud, Sigmund
Science
Wit and its relation to the unconscious
Freud, Sigmund
Subconsciousness; Wit and humor -- Psychological aspects
The comic of comparison thus becomes reduced to a case of
degradation.
The comparison, as we have seen above, can now be witty without a trace
of comic admixture, especially when it happens to evade the degradation.
Thus the comparison of Truth to a torch which one cannot carry through a
crowd without singeing somebody’s beard is pure wit, because it takes an
obsolete expression (“The torch of truth”) at its full value and not at
all in a comical sense, and because the torch as an object does not lack
a certain distinction, though it is a concrete object. However, a
comparison may just as well be witty as comic, and what is more one may
be independent of the other, in that the comparison becomes an aid for
certain techniques of wit, as, for example, unification or allusion.
Thus Nestroy’s comparison of memory to a “Warehouse” (p. 120) is
simultaneously comical and witty, first, on account of the extraordinary
degradation to which the psychological conception must consent in the
comparison to a “Warehouse,” and secondly, because he who utilizes the
comparison is a clerk, and in this comparison he establishes a rather
unexpected unification between psychology and his vocation. Heine’s
verse, “until at last the buttons tore from the pants of my patience,”
seems at first an excellent example of a comic degrading comparison, but
on closer reflection we must ascribe to it also the attribute of
wittiness, since the comparison as a means of allusion strikes into the
realm of the obscene and causes a release of pleasure from the obscene.
Through a union not altogether incidental the same material also gives
us a resultant pleasure which is at the same time comical and witty; it
does not matter whether or not the conditions of the one promote the
origin of the other, such a union acts confusingly on the “feeling”
whose function it is to announce to us whether we have before us wit or
the comic, and only a careful examination independent of the disposition
of pleasure can decide the question.
As tempting as it would be to trace these more intimate determinations
of comic pleasure, the author must remember that neither his previous
education nor his daily vocation justifies him in extending his
investigations beyond the spheres of wit, and he must confess that it is
precisely the subject of comic comparison which makes him feel his
incompetence.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account