Wit and its relation to the unconsciousFreud, Sigmund
Science
Wit and its relation to the unconscious
Freud, Sigmund
Subconsciousness; Wit and humor -- Psychological aspects
d) The occasion for releasing comic pleasure vanishes when the attention
is fixed on the comparison capable of giving rise to the comic. Under
such circumstances the comic force is lost from that which is otherwise
sure to produce a comic effect. A movement or a mental activity cannot
become comical to him whose interest is fixed at the time of comparing
this movement with a standard which distinctly presents itself to him.
Thus the examiner does not see the comical in the nonsense produced by
the student in his ignorance; he is simply annoyed by it, whereas the
offender’s classmates who are more interested in his chances of passing
the examination than in what he knows, laugh heartily over the same
nonsense. The teacher of dancing or gymnastics seldom has any eyes for
the comic movements of his pupils, and the preacher entirely loses sight
of humanity’s defects of character, which the writer of comedy brings
out with so much effect. The comic process cannot stand examination by
the attention, it must be able to proceed absolutely unnoticed in a
manner similar to wit. But for good reasons, it would contradict the
nomenclature of “conscious processes” which I have used in _The
Interpretation of Dreams_, if one wished to call it of necessity
_unconscious_. It rather belongs to the _foreconscious_, and one may use
the fitting name “automatic” for all those processes which are enacted
in the foreconscious and dispense with the attention energy which is
connected with consciousness. The process of comparison of the
expenditures must remain automatic if it is to produce comic pleasure.
_Conditions Disturbing the Discharge_
e) It is exceedingly disturbing to the comic if the case from which it
originates gives rise at the same time to a marked release of affect.
The discharge of the affective difference is then as a rule excluded.
Affects, disposition, and the attitude of the individual in occasional
cases make it clear that the comic comes or goes with the viewpoint of
the individual person; that only in exceptional cases is there an
absolute comic. The dependence or relativity of the comic is therefore
much greater than of wit, which never happens but is regularly made, and
at its production one may already give attention to the conditions under
which it finds acceptance. But affective development is the most
intensive of the conditions which disturb the comic, the significance of
which is well known.[79] It is therefore said that the comic feeling
comes most in tolerably indifferent cases which evince no strong
feelings or interests. Nevertheless it is just in cases with affective
release that one may witness the production of a particularly strong
expenditure-difference in the automatism of discharge. When Colonel
Butler answers Octavio’s admonitions with “bitter laughter,” exclaiming:
“Thanks from the house of Austria!”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account