Wit and its relation to the unconsciousFreud, Sigmund
Science
Wit and its relation to the unconscious
Freud, Sigmund
Subconsciousness; Wit and humor -- Psychological aspects
As an illustration I can point to the story cited on page 112 in which
the Jew in the train immediately abandons all sense of decency of
deportment as soon as he recognizes the new arrival in his coupé as his
coreligionist. We have come to know this joke as an illustration by
means of a detail—representation through a trifle; it is supposed to
represent the democratic mode of thought of the Jew who recognizes no
difference between master and servant, but unfortunately this also
disturbs discipline and co-operation. Another especially interesting
series of jokes presents the relationship between the poor and the rich
Jews: their heroes are the “shnorrer,”[44] and the charitable gentleman
or the baron. _The shnorrer, who was a regular Sunday-dinner guest at a
certain house, appeared one day accompanied by a young stranger, who
prepared to seat himself at the table. “Who is that?” demanded the host.
“He became my son-in-law last week,” was the reply, “and I have agreed
to supply his board for the first year.”_ The tendency of these stories
is always the same, and is most distinctly shown in the following story.
_The shnorrer supplicates the baron for money to visit the bathing
resort Ostend, as the physician has ordered him to take sea baths for
his ailment. The baron remarks that Ostend is an especially expensive
resort, and that a less fashionable place would do just as well. But the
shnorrer rejects that proposition by saying, “Herr Baron, nothing is too
expensive for my health.”_ That is an excellent displacement-witticism
which we could have taken as a model of its kind. The baron is evidently
anxious to save his money, but the shnorrer replies as if the baron’s
money were his own, which he may then consider secondary to his health.
One is forced to laugh at the insolence of the demand, but these jokes
are exceptionally unequipped with a façade to becloud the understanding.
The truth is that the shnorrer who mentally treats the rich man’s money
as his own, really possesses almost the right to this mistake, according
to the sacred codes of the Jews. Naturally the resistance which is
responsible for this joke is directed against the law which even the
pious find very oppressing.
Another story relates _how on the steps of a rich man’s house a shnorrer
met one of his own kind. The latter counseled him to depart, saying, “Do
not go up to-day, the Baron is out of sorts and refuses to give any one
more than a dollar.” “I will go up anyway,” replied the first. “Why in
the world should I make him, a present of a dollar? Is he making me any
presents?”_
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account