With the movie makersStearns, Myron M. (Myron Morris)
General
With the movie makers
Stearns, Myron M. (Myron Morris)
Motion pictures -- Juvenile literature
So, we can lead the world, if we will. But unfortunately, those two
pictures are exceptions. One can name a few more, like “Little Lord
Fauntleroy,” “Humoresque,” and “Over the Hill,” that are good enough
to hold their own with the best producers elsewhere; but that is about
all. The run of our American-made pictures are not good enough, to-day,
to deserve world supremacy.
That is something to think about.
The German pictures, as well as those of some of the other foreign
countries, have certain qualities, resulting from an unwillingness
to compromise with ideals, that allow them, as a class, to outrank
ours. For instance, while the Germans desire beauty, just as we do,
and would like to have their heroine as beautiful as ours, they also
desire a real ability to act. If they can not have both, they will
let the beauty go, and take the real acting. We will not; we let
the ability go, and stick to the pretty flappers. Accordingly, in
American pictures, our leading actors and actresses are almost always
good-looking—and frequently poor at acting.
It is the same about truth, or the sense of reality. We sacrifice
convincingness—fidelity to life—truth—to our desire for youth and
beauty. If we could have both, well and good; but it is impossible.
Accordingly, on the American screen, we see, again and again, our
beautiful little flapper friends playing parts that should be taken by
older women—not so young and pretty, perhaps, but true to life, instead
of childish caricatures of truth.
Even with Griffith’s “Orphans of the Storm,” we see still another
sacrifice of an ideal—one might almost say principle. That is the
giving up of historical value, and big things, for excitement, and
little things. The French Revolution is a tremendous story in itself;
in the foreign made films it is made the backbone of the whole story;
in Griffith’s film, it is merely a background, while the “main” story
is centered about one or two appealing characters, that mean, except
for momentary entertainment, little or nothing. It is a question of
Lillian and Dorothy Gish being more important, on this side of the
Atlantic, than the French Revolution; but on the other side, when
the French Revolution is filmed, it is more important than the great
actress who plays in the picture—Pola Negri.
Also, in the mad “run to the rescue” in “Orphans of the Storm,” the
main dramatic value of the story is sacrificed in order to have the
mechanically produced excitement of horses galloping across Paris in
time to save the beautiful Lillian from the guillotine. And who leads
the headlong, melodramatic dash across the city? Why, Danton himself,
leader of the Revolution! That’s putting it on pretty thick!
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account