Your boy and his training : $b A practical treatise on boy-trainingPuller, Edwin Seward
Science
Your boy and his training : $b A practical treatise on boy-training
Puller, Edwin Seward
Boys; Child rearing
The gradual recognition, by an aroused public conscience, of the evil
results of such a system put into operation the forces which in many
states have abolished the old plan of regarding and punishing the child
as a criminal and substituted the principle that the wayward child is
a dependent whom the state, like a wise parent, will restrain from
evil and educate in the paths leading to good citizenship, through
the agency of the juvenile court and its efficient aid, the probation
officer.
We now recognize the inability of the child to commit a crime, judged
by the standards applicable to the adult criminal, for the reason
that his mental and moral concepts have not yet reached the stage of
development which can distinguish between right and wrong with the
clearness of the adult. What in the adult with full consciousness of
the import and effects of his acts would be trespass, assault and
battery, larceny, and burglary, are in the child varied forms of
moral disease which it is the state’s business to cure--not punish. It
is conceded that it would be monstrous and brutal to punish a child
for contracting measles, scarlet fever, or whooping cough, and it is
equally monstrous for the state to punish the same child before he
attains moral maturity, for contracting a moral disease which manifests
itself in acts which are crimes only when committed by adults with full
comprehension of their moral significance.
Again we revert for our guidance to the child’s viewpoint which in many
instances is closely akin to that of the untutored savage. During a
summer which I spent in the wilderness of the great woods of the North
I encountered an Indian who habitually killed deer out of season and
in violation of the laws of the state in which he lived. When I asked
him why he did not obey the law, he replied, “God made deer for Indian
before white man made book [the law].” From his viewpoint, he was not
guilty of wrongdoing in killing deer to supply food for his family;
from the viewpoint of the law he was a lawbreaker.
The underlying principle of the operation of children’s courts is
the recognition of the fact that the offender under sixteen years
of age should not be judged or punished by adult standards; that he
should not be arrested, indicted, convicted, imprisoned, or punished
as a criminal. Evidence of the offense is not regarded as proof of
criminality but rather as light on the question as to how the state,
standing _in loco parentis_, can best exercise its parental function
in the formation of the embryo character needed to make the boy a good
citizen.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account