Zanzibar; city, island, and coast. Vol. 1 (of 2)Burton, Richard Francis, Sir
History
Zanzibar; city, island, and coast. Vol. 1 (of 2)
Burton, Richard Francis, Sir
Africa, East -- Description and travel; Ethnology -- Tanzania -- Zanzibar; Zanzibar -- Description and travel
Firstly, Mr Wakefield, like Doctors Livingstone and Kirk, all being
practical linguists, invariably uses the system of Zangian
orthography, adopted by the ‘Mombas Mission,’ and by myself since
1859. He speaks, for instance, of Kilima-njaro and Unyamwezi, not the
Monomoezi of Mr Cooley or ‘the authentic word Mueni Muezi,’ translated
landlord, or petty chief country (p. 11, The Memoir on the Lake
Regions of East Africa reviewed, &c. &c., by W. D. Cooley. London:
Stanford, 1864). We find in Mr Wakefield’s Notes (p. 316) ‘_Líma_, a
term denoting extraordinary size—Mlíma being the general term for
mountain,’ whilst (p. 321) Ki-Mrima is justly applied to the dialect
spoken on the Mrima or mainland facing Zanzibar Island. We read also
(323) ‘Mtanganyíko,[126] Kisawáhílí, meaning the place of _mingling_
or _mixture_ (rendezvous).’ This is precisely the meaning attached by
me to the Lake’s name, yet I was assured in the Memoir above alluded
to (p. 7) that nothing can be ‘more ridiculous’ than my explanation of
Tanganyika. Even in philological details of the Kisawahili dialect Mr
Wakefield agrees with me. He writes, for instance, Udogo (Notes, p.
313), Ugala (Footprints, p. 67, 68), and Ulangulo (Ibid. p. 63). I was
assured in the Memoir (p. 9) that U is prefixed to the names of
countries only by Dr Krapf and Captain Burton—this, too, after I had
for years been talking of Europe as Uzungu, literally, Land of white
men. Mr Wakefield speaks of Wasămbá, of Wasawahili (or Wa-Sawahili),
and of Wanyamwezi, thus sanctioning the use of Wamrima, continental
men, and Wakilima, hill-men. He adopts Kisawahili, Kikwavi, Kimasai,
and so forth, prefixing an adjectival particle ‘Ki’ to the root, and
denoting chiefly dialect, yet I was assured by Mr Cooley (Memoir, p.
9) that ‘Ki’ has never an adjectival form. I may now invite the author
of Inner Africa Laid Open to revise the verdict (Memoir, p. 7) which
pronounces me ‘totally ignorant’ of the language of which I affect to
be master.
It may be deemed trivial to dwell upon these philological minutiæ, but,
firstly, nothing is unimportant when it affects the accuracy of a
traveller, especially of an explorer, in the smallest matters of detail.
Secondly, without an exact nomenclature all topographical literature
must be imperfect and of scant value. And, finally, as Mr Cooley and I
have been differing upon these points for the last ten years, it is well
that the portion of the public which takes an interest in the subject
should see who is right and who is not. I have no personal feeling in
the matter; and if the ‘Geographer of N’yassi’ will bring, as I have
done, independent testimony to bear upon the points in question, and not
evolve his learning out of the depths of his self-consciousness, I am at
all times ready and willing to own myself wrong.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account