an arrogant false astronomy, of an equally false and presumptuous
geology, or a suicidal method of reasoning--a logic which never demands
a proof of its premises, and which therefore leads to conclusions
which are contrary to nature, to human experience, and to the direct
teaching of God’s word, and therefore contrary to the deepest and
most lasting interests of humanity. “God has spoken to man in two
voices, the voice of inspiration and the voice of nature. By man’s
ignorance they have been made to disagree; but the time will come, and
cannot be far distant, when these two languages will strictly accord;
when the science of nature will no longer contradict the science of
scripture.”[46]
[46] Professor Hunt.
CUI BONO.--“Of all terrors to the generous soul, that _Cui bono_ is
the one to be the most zealously avoided. Whether it be proposed to
find the magnetic point, or a passage impossible to be utilised if
discovered, or a race of men of no good to any human institution
extant, and of no good to themselves; or to seek the Unicorn in
Madagascar, and when we had found him not to be able to make use of
him; or the great central plateau of Australia, where no one could
live for centuries to come; or the great African lake, which, for all
the good it would do us English folk might as well be in the Moon;
or the source of the Nile, the triumphant discovery of which would
neither lower the rents nor take off the taxes anywhere--whatever it
is, the _Cui bono_ is always a weak and cowardly argument: essentially
short-sighted too, seeing that, according to the law of the past, by
which we may always safely predicate the future, so much falls into
the hands of the seeker, for which he was not looking, and of which
he never even knew the existence. The area of the possible is very
wide still, and very insignificant and minute, the angle we have
staked out and marked impossible. What do we know of the powers which
nature has yet in reserve, of the secrets she has still untold, the
wealth still concealed? Every day sees new discoveries in the sciences
we can investigate at home. What, then, may not lie waiting for the
explorers abroad? Weak and short-sighted commercially, the _cui bono_
is worse than both, morally. When we remember the powerful manhood,
the patience, unselfishness, courage, devotion, and nobleness of aim
which must accompany a perilous enterprise, and which form so great an
example, and so heart-stirring to the young and to the wavering, it is
no return to barbaric indifference to life to say, better indeed a few
deaths for even a commercially useless enterprise--better a few hearths
made desolate, and a few wives and mothers left to bear their stately
sorrow to the end of time, that the future may rejoice and be strong:
better a thousand failures, and a thousand useless undertakings,
than the loss of national manhood or the weakening of the national
fibre. Quixotism is a folly when the energy which might have achieved
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account