DATE OF THE “MONARCHIA.”--The _Monarchia_ is Dante’s attempt to solve
this burning mediaeval question of the proper relations of Church and
State, of spiritual and temporal authority. Although it is undoubtedly
the most famous of his prose works, the most widely divergent views
have been held as to its date of composition. If the _Vita Nuova_
is the most ideal book of love, the _Monarchia_ is one of the most
purely idealistic works ever written on politics. Even as Beatrice is
the most glorious lady of the poet’s mind, _la gloriosa donna de la
mia mente_, so the temporal monarchy or Empire is to be considered by
the poet in its ideal aspect according to the divine intention, _typo
et secundum intentionem_ (_Mon._ i. 2). Like the _Vita Nuova_, and
unlike any other of Dante’s longer works, the _Monarchia_ contains no
mention of the poet’s exile, and no explicit references or allusions to
contemporary events or persons. From this, and other considerations,
it has sometimes been held that the _Monarchia_ was written during
his political life in Florence. Boccaccio, on the other hand, declares
that Dante made this book on the coming of Henry VII., and the trend of
criticism to-day is to accept 1313 as the approximate date. There are,
however, scholars who consider it more probable that the _Monarchia_
was written towards the close of the poet’s life.
BOOK I.--The _Monarchia_ is divided into three books, corresponding
to the three questions to be answered touching this most useful and
least explored amongst occult and useful truths, the knowledge of the
temporal monarchy (i. 1). In its ideal sense, the temporal Monarchy, or
Empire, is defined as “a unique princedom extending over all persons
in time, or in and over those things which are measured by time” (i.
2). And the first question arising concerning this temporal Monarchy
is--whether it is necessary for the well-being of the world.
The proper function of the human race taken as a whole, the ultimate
end or goal, for which the eternal God by His art, which is nature,
brings into being the human race in its universality, is constantly
to actualise or bring into play the whole capacity of the possible
intellect, for contemplation and for action, for speculation and for
operation (i. 3). And, for this almost divine function and goal, the
most direct means is universal peace (i. 4). Since it is ordained for
this goal, the human race must be guided by one ruling power, the
Emperor, with reference to whom all its parts have their order; in
subjection to whom, the human race becomes in its unity most like to
God (i. 5-9). There must be some one supreme judge to decide by his
judgment, mediately or immediately, all contentions; and such a judge
can only be the Monarch (i. 10).