The English works of Thomas Hobbes of Malmesbury, Volume 02 (of 11) — Thomas Hobbes — John Shaqi
The English works of Thomas Hobbes of Malmesbury, Volume 02 (of 11)
Thomas Hobbes · en
[Sidenote: A monarch retaining his right of government, cannot, by
any promise whatsoever, be conceived to have parted with
his right to the means necessary to the exercise of his
authority.]
17. If the monarch _promise_ aught to any one or many subjects
together, by consequence whereof the exercise of his power may
suffer prejudice, that _promise_ or _compact_, whether made by oath
or without it, is null. For all _compact_ is a conveyance of right,
which by what hath been said in the fourth article of the second
chapter, requires meet and proper signs of the will in the conveyer.
But he who sufficiently signifies his will of retaining the end,
doth also sufficiently declare that he quits not his right to the
means necessary to that end. Now he who hath promised to part with
somewhat necessary to the supreme power, and yet retains the power
itself, gives sufficient tokens that he no otherwise promised it,
than so far forth as the power might be retained without it.
Whensoever therefore it shall appear, that what is promised cannot
be performed without prejudice to the power, the promise must be
valued as not made, that is, of no effect.
[Sidenote: By what means a subject is freed from his subjection.]
18. We have seen how subjects, nature dictating, have obliged
themselves by mutual compacts to obey the supreme power. We will see
now by what means it comes to pass, that they are released from
these bonds of obedience. And first of all, this happens by
_rejection_, namely, if a man cast off or forsake, but convey not
the _right of his command_ on some other. For what is thus rejected,
is openly exposed to all alike, catch who catch can; whence again,
by the right of nature, every subject may heed the preservation of
himself according to his own judgment. In the second place, if the
kingdom fall into the power of the enemy, so as there can no more
opposition be made against them, we must understand that he who
before had the supreme authority, hath now lost it: for when the
subjects have done their full endeavour to prevent their falling
into the enemy’s hands, they have fulfilled those contracts of
obedience which they made each with other; and what, being
conquered, they promise afterwards to avoid death, they must with no
less endeavour labour to perform. Thirdly, in a monarchy, (for a
democracy and aristocracy cannot fail), if there be no successor,
all the subjects are discharged from their obligations; for no man
is supposed to be tied he knows not to whom; for in such a case it
were impossible to perform aught. And by these three ways, all
subjects are restored from their civil subjection to that liberty
which all men have to all things; to wit, natural and savage; for
the natural state hath the same proportion to the civil, (I mean,
liberty to subjection), which passion hath to reason, or a beast to
a man. Furthermore, each subject may lawfully be freed from his