The English works of Thomas Hobbes of Malmesbury, Volume 07 (of 11)
Thomas Hobbes · en
_B._ If that were so, it would still be ice, though also crystal: which
cannot be, because crystal is heavier than water, and therefore much
heavier than ice.
_A._ Is there then no transubstantiation of bodies but by mixture?
_B._ Mixture is no transubstantiation.
_A._ Have you never seen a stone that seemed to have been formerly wood,
and some like shells, and some like serpents, and others like other
things?
_B._ Yes. I have seen such things, and particularly I saw at Rome, in a
stone-cutter’s workhouse, a billet of wood, as I thought it, partly
covered with bark, and partly with the grain bare, as long as a man’s
arm, and as thick as the calf of a man’s leg; which handling I found
extreme heavy, and saw a small part of it which was polished, and had a
very fine gloss, and thought it a substance between stone and metal, but
nearest to stone. I have seen also a kind of slate painted naturally
with forest-work. And I have seen in the hands of a chemist of my
acquaintance at Paris, a broken glass, part of a retort, in which had
been the rosin of turpentine, wherein though there were left no rosin,
yet there appeared in the piece of glass many trees; and plants in the
ground about them, such as grow in woods; and better designed than they
could be done by any painter; and continued so for a long time. These be
great wonders of nature, but I will not undertake to show their causes.
But yet this is most certain, that nothing can make a hard body of a
soft, but by some motion of its parts. For the parts of the hardest body
in the world can be no closer together than to touch; and so close are
the parts of air and water, and consequently they should be equally
hard, if their smallest parts had not different natural motions.
Therefore if you ask me the causes of these effects, I answer, they are
different motions. But if you expect from me how and by what motions, I
shall fail you. For there is no kind of substance in the world now, that
was not at the first creation, when the Creator gave to all things what
natural and special motion he thought good. And as he made some bodies
wondrous great, so he made others wondrous little. For all his works are
wondrous. Man can but guess, nor guess farther, than he hath knowledge
of the variety of motion. I am therefore of opinion, that whatsoever
perfectly homogeneous is hard, consisteth of the smallest parts, or, as
some call them, atoms, that were made hard in the beginning, and
consequently by an eternal cause; and that the hardness of the whole
body is caused only by the contact of the parts by pressure.
_A._ What motion is it that maketh a hard body to melt?