"They are children, more or less stupid," said Montrose with conviction,
"and can grasp very little. Since Mr. Sparrow teaches them to love God
and love their neighbour, he is doing all that he can do. But he could
colour the greyness of his sermon: he could speak in parables as the
Master did. Then he would arrest their attention, and some ideas, if
put picturesquely, would stick in their minds. A man will forget a
series of admonitions if stated baldly: he will certainly remember some
if connected with a story."
"Perhaps," said Alice doubtfully. "But Mr. Sparrow is a really good
man."
"Isn't that rather irrelevant?" observed the young man dryly. "I quite
admit that he is a good man. It is not his fault that the Church has
lost her esoteric knowledge, which was reserved for the intellectual,
who wished to believe with the head as well as with the heart. But he is
only a sample of many parsons. His intentions are of the best, but he
does not speak with conviction to my mind."
"He is a true believer," urged the girl, rather distressed.
"I am sure he is everything that is genuine and kind," replied her
lover, a trifle impatiently. "But he lacks that wisdom which comes from
logical reasoning on the things he discourses about."
"But can religion be proved logically?"
"Certainly; but only when one knows the esoteric teaching which the
Church had, but which the Church has lost. Eberstein has taught much of
it to me during the last three years, and there are few questions
connected with religion and the Bible which I cannot answer in at least
a reasonable way. Go to Mr. Sparrow and he will assure you that half the
questions you ask are a mystery into which you must not pry. What is the
result, Alice?"
"I'm sure I can't say," she answered good-humouredly.
"The result is," continued Montrose, growing more vehement, "that
whenever a man begins to think, he leaves the Church from sheer
inability to gain the information which is needed to reconcile what is
taught with common sense. Only the people who don't think, who are
Christians because they happen to have been brought up Christians,
remain in the Church, and accept emotionally and blindly whatever is
told them on ecclesiastical authority. That, when examined, is no
authority at all to the thinking man."
"And the inner teaching?"