Life and Correspondence of David Hume, Volume 2 — David Hume — John Shaqi
Life and Correspondence of David Hume, Volume 2
David Hume · en
At last came the full outpouring of the long-treasured wrath, in a
letter dated the 10th of July, as long as an ordinary pamphlet, and
penned with the same neat precision as its predecessor. The reader will
not expect a document so well known and easily accessible to be
reprinted; and an abridgment would fail to give any notion of the rabid
eloquence with which the most paltry incidents are made to assume the
appearance of portentous charges; until, through vehemence of expression
and multitude of powerful words, they seem for the moment to acquire
substantial shape. Many of the charges contained in this "indictment"
have been already alluded to. The document begins with a statement of
its author's candour,[337:2] and hatred of every kind of artifice; and
no one can read the charges which follow, monstrously absurd as they
are, without seeing that they are made in the perfect sincerity of a
mind that saw all things through its own diseased medium. The following
is one of the substantive charges:--
I was informed that the son of the quack Tronchin,[338:1] my
most mortal enemy, was not only the friend of Mr. Hume, and
under his protection, but that they both lodged in the same
house; and when Mr. Hume found that I knew this, he imparted
it in confidence to me; assuring me that the son by no means
resembled the father. I lodged a few nights myself, together
with my governante, in the same house; and from the kind of
reception with which we were honoured by the landladies, who
are his friends, I judged in what manner either Mr. Hume, or
that man, who, as he said, was by no means like his father,
must have spoken to them both of her and me.
All these facts put together, added to a certain appearance of
things on the whole, insensibly gave me an uneasiness, which I
rejected with horror.
The description of the following scene must have been, to those who knew
Hume personally, irresistibly ludicrous. The picture of the phlegmatic
reserve of English manners, is made perfect by contrast. It appears from
Hume's letter, that the scene arose out of the dispute about the return
chaise.
One evening, after supper, as we were sitting silent by the
fireside, I caught his eyes intently fixed on me, as indeed
happened very often; and that in a manner of which it is very
difficult to give an idea. At that time he gave me a
steadfast, piercing look, mingled with a sneer, which greatly
disturbed me. To get rid of my embarrassment, I endeavoured to
look full at him in my turn; but, in fixing my eyes upon his,
I felt the most inexpressible terror, and was soon obliged to
turn them away. The speech and physiognomy of the good David
are those of an honest man; but where, great God! did this
honest man borrow those eyes which he fixes on his friends?