Philosophumena; or, The refutation of all heresies, Volume II
David Hume · en
[Footnote 10: τοῦ λόγου ἀκούσαντας, “listen to the argument.”
Hippolytus had he written in English would doubtless have said “the
Word,” but this has a different connotation in modern language.]
[Footnote 11: λόγος without the article.]
[Footnote 12: ἀπείροισιν ἐοίκασι πειρεώμενοι. It is very difficult
to make sense of these words and both Cruice and Macmahon leave them
untranslated.]
[Footnote 13: πεττεύων. Playing at _tessera_ or draughts. Cr.,
_tesseras jaciens_, a game in which there was chance as well as skill
like backgammon. Lucian, as Cruice notes, puts the same phrase into
Heraclitus’ mouth.]
[Footnote 14: Some word missing here.]
[Footnote 15: κρείττων supplied from the next quoted sentence.]
[Footnote 16: The Codex has ὅσον ὄψις κ.τ.λ. Cruice substitutes ὅσων
and translates _Quaecumque visus ... capere possunt_.]
[Footnote 17: Something probably omitted here also.]
[Footnote 18: ἕτερον.]
[Footnote 19: A screw. Also a staircase.]
[Footnote 20: ὀλέθριον, “destructive.”]
[Footnote 21: χρημοσύνη. Cr., _Inopia_, Macm., “Craving.”]
[Footnote 22: διακόσμησις. The making of a cosmos out of chaos or the
Creation.]
[Footnote 23: So Clem. Alex., _Strom._, V, 1, makes Heraclitus predict
the destruction of the world by fire. The same theory is attributed to
the Stoics.]
[Footnote 24: It has not been thought well to delay the reader by
attempting to puzzle out the meaning of Heraclitus whom the ancients
themselves did not profess to understand. So far as can be seen the
only likeness between his sayings and the teaching of Noetus and his
successors was due to the love of paradox shown by both. The parallel
between them that Hippolytus tries to draw is mainly forced upon him by
his own theory that all heresy is derived from Greek philosophy.]
[Footnote 25: A pun on νοητός, the adjective, and Noetus, the proper
name.]
[Footnote 26: Another pun between ἁιρουμένοι and αἵρεσις.]
[Footnote 27: The words in brackets supplied from the Summary in Book
X.]
[Footnote 28: Ἀχώρητος, “that cannot be confined (in space),” or what
we mean when we say that He is infinite.]
[Footnote 29: ἀκράτητος, “that cannot be dominated.” One would have
expected the word ἀνίκητος; but as this was one of the honorific titles
of the Emperor, it was doubtless altered for prudential reasons.]
[Footnote 30: Not “sovereignty” but the doctrine of One Source and
Ruler of All. The phrase constantly recurs in the theology of the time,
and the word Monarchian is applied to all heresies of the Noetian kind.]