"Ah, we all know the omniscience of critics! They are truly wonderful
men, before whose vast experience and knowledge I remain dumb. And the
rapidity of their work, their marvellous grasp of every subject in
literature, from a Child's Primer to a novel of George Meredith's.
Nothing appalls them, nothing daunts them. Oh, what wonderful men they
are! truly wonderful, so calm, so learned, so kind-hearted. Why do you
know, Macjean, I met a critic once who thought nothing of Dickens as
an author! Think of that! Think of the wonderful mind of that man who
could afford to speak contemptuously about one of the master spirits
of the age."
"Did he write books himself?" asked Otterburn, shrewdly, at which
Eustace looked at him in grave reproof.
"Of course not," he replied quietly, "he was a most self-denying man.
He did write one novel I believe, but it was so far in advance of our
present age that the publisher was afraid to print it--fancy that, a
publisher afraid! Well, it was so, and now this critic only reviews
other people's books--what self-denial. And then his decisions. Why he
makes up his mind about a book, that has taken months to write, in
five minutes. I've known him analyse a book without cutting the leaves
to read it. Of course it is marvellous, simply marvellous, but our age
is prolific in such clever men. I've met many such, and always felt
like a whipped schoolboy before their calm, clear gaze. If you boil
down twenty of our best authors you may make one critic, but then it's
quality not quantity."
"I thought you did not like critics?"
"Not like critics, my dear fellow?" said Eustace sweetly, "why they
are my dearest friends, my best benefactors. They always read my
books, and give half an hour to each, actually a whole half hour. What
friendship! And then, you know, they are so kind, they point out all
my mistakes, and if I copy any ideas of foreign authors, they always
look them up to see if I have done so correctly, and mention
it--really mention it--in their articles. If there is anything naughty
in my chapters, they reprove me, oh, so kindly, and tell the public
where to look for the worst bits. And then they are so modest; they
never tell me they wrote these articles, when I meet them in society.
I always put my name to my books, they never do to their articles, and
yet my books are full of mistakes which they try to correct for me."
"How kind of them?"