A System of Logic, Ratiocinative and Inductive (Vol. 1 of 2)
John Stuart Mill · en
§ 4. In the case of sensations, another distinction has also to be kept in
view, which is often confounded, and never without mischievous
consequences. This is, the distinction between the sensation itself, and
the state of the bodily organs which precedes the sensation, and which
constitutes the physical agency by which it is produced. One of the
sources of confusion on this subject is the division commonly made of
feelings into Bodily and Mental. Philosophically speaking, there is no
foundation at all for this distinction: even sensations are states of the
sentient mind, not states of the body, as distinguished from it. What I am
conscious of when I see the colour blue, is a feeling of blue colour,
which is one thing; the picture on my retina, or the phenomenon of
hitherto mysterious nature which takes place in my optic nerve or in my
brain, is another thing, of which I am not at all conscious, and which
scientific investigation alone could have apprised me of. These are states
of my body; but the sensation of blue, which is the consequence of these
states of body, is not a state of body: that which perceives and is
conscious is called Mind. When sensations are called bodily feelings, it
is only as being the class of feelings which are immediately occasioned by
bodily states; whereas the other kinds of feelings, thoughts, for
instance, or emotions, are immediately excited not by anything acting upon
the bodily organs, but by sensations, or by previous thoughts. This,
however, is a distinction not in our feelings, but in the agency which
produces our feelings: all of them when actually produced are states of
mind.
Besides the affection of our bodily organs from without, and the sensation
thereby produced in our minds, many writers admit a third link in the
chain of phenomena, which they call a Perception, and which consists in
the recognition of an external object as the exciting cause of the
sensation. This perception, they say, is an _act_ of the mind, proceeding
from its own spontaneous activity; while in sensation the mind is passive,
being merely acted upon by the outward object. And according to some
metaphysicians it is by an act of the mind, similar to perception, except
in not being preceded by any sensation, that the existence of God, the
soul, and other hyperphysical objects is recognised.