The philosophical and mathematical commentaries of Proclus on the first book of Euclid's elements (Vol. 1 of 2) : $b To which are added, A history of the restoration of Platonic theology, by the latter Platonists: And a translation from the Greek of Proclus's Theological elements
Plato · en
21. One science is said to be prior to, and more certain than another
in many respects;--when the one reasons from primary causes, but the
other from such as are secondary:--when the one may be ranked in the
genera of intelligibles and universals; but the other in the genera of
sensibles and particulars. And such is the relation of arithmetic to
music; of geometry to optics; and lastly, of every superior to every
subordinate science. Again, this happens when the one reasons from
simple principles, the other from such as are complex and connected;
on which account arithmetic seems to possess greater certainty than
geometry. For the principle of arithmetic is unity; but of geometry
a point; and unity is without position, with which a point is always
connected. And in this manner geometry inherits greater evidence than
astronomy; for the one considers body simply, the other as connected
with a circular motion. The science is called one which contemplates
actions belonging to one genus: the genus is one which possesses the
same first principles; and hence geometry and stereometry form one
science. On the contrary, the sciences are called different which have
different principles, such as geometry and optics; the latter of which
does not originate from the principles of the former.
Again, the same thing may admit of many demonstrations, and may be
known from many mediums: at one time from the application of such
as are congenial: at another, from those of a different order or
genus. From congenials, as when we demonstrate that the plantain is a
substance, first, by the medium of a tree, and then by the medium of a
plant, thus:
Every tree is a substance;
The plantain is a tree:
Therefore the plantain is a substance. And again,
Every plant is a substance:
The plantain is a plant:
Therefore the plantain is a substance.
We demonstrate, from mediums, of a following order or genus, as when we
prove man to be a substance, at one one time from his being rational,
at another from his being a biped; and these mediums, in part, mutually
contain each other.
22. Fortuitous events can never, in any science, become the subject
of demonstration; since they are neither limited by necessity, nor
admit the arrangement of syllogism. Indeed, so far from obtaining
a necessary, they do not possess a frequent existence, but every
syllogism is composed from one or other of these.