Abu Hanifa and Hadith: Seventeen Hadiths or Fifteen Musnads?
Ibn Khaldun records the claim that Abu Hanifa's narrations reached only seventeen hadiths — yet fifteen separate musnads of his transmissions were later combined into one book. Al-Khatib's Tarikh Baghdad holds both the longest praise and the longest indictment of the same man. Open the books and decide.
By John Shaqi · July 23, 2026 · 15 min read
Two Numbers, One Man
In the chapter on the sciences of hadith in his Muqaddima, Ibn Khaldun (d. 808 AH) sets three numbers side by side. The Musnad of Ahmad ibn Hanbal, he writes, contains fifty thousand hadiths. Malik accepted as sound only what he placed in the Muwatta — some three hundred, on Ibn Khaldun's count. Then comes this sentence about the earliest of the four imams:
فيقال إنها بلغت سبعة عشر حديثاً أو نحوها
Continue Reading
Continue reading this article
Sign in free to read in full. Become a member to join the discussion without limits.
Sign in free to read →- ✓Read every article
- ✓Comment and reply (up to 100 words, 10/month)
- ✓Browse the community
- ✓Reader badge